Unicode is full of dingbats, most of which display properly in all modern software: http://www.fileformat.info/info/unicode/block/dingbats/utf8t...
Fair enough. If they used them though, they might get sniped at for not sticking to web conventions. There's no cover from snipers on the internet.
There might be reasons not to as well - I imagine they break some bookmark tools, etc.
Regardless, I'm guessing the editor of the New Yorker has been to their website. Her approval defines what it is that the New Yorker does, and what it is known for. Sniping at such an organization previously known for pedantry is a bit presumptuous.