For example: Search for [msnbc], and it shows up as “msnbc.com” … title tag: “Breaking News, Weather, Business, Health, Entertainment, Sports, Politics, Travel, Science, Technology, Local, US & World News – msnbc.com”
[new yorker] shows up as “The New Yorker” … title tag: “National and world news, Profiles, culture, reviews, fiction, poetry : The New Yorker”
[redfin] shows up as “Redfin” … title tag: “Search Homes for Sale & Find Real Estate Agents Who Put You First | Redfin”
None of those pages have opensearch documents.
It appears that the actual purpose of the opensearch xml document is to describe the search engine which exists on the homepage of airbnb.com. That explains why more sites don't do it. It isn't actually relevant unless you are running a custom search engine.
We have updated the blog post, and I'm sorry for the confusion about this point. Still, I very much believe in the takeaway message that it is important to craft a strong title for your website.
As long as we're all here obsessing on title tags:
Apples, Oranges, Potatoes | Farmly
is my go-to template for a title tag. You'll find in very competitive verticals the title is more optimized and less English, e.g. by not having the natural "and" before Potatoes.
Companies not dependent on rankings for customers acquisition can use the title tag to compete for CTR on the SERP. This is most relevant to companies with very recognizable brands. e.g. see whatever Amazon's title is now. Almost everybody will maximize for search engines on leaf node pages.