News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by echelon on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:40AM (#20263953)
Once big auto moves to EVs, what will happen to Tesla? Will they have a significant foothold/advantage, or will their position erode? Will they get acquired or remain independent?
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by bryanlarsen on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:52AM (#20264097)
- Tesla currently has a huge efficiency advantage[1]

- Tesla's Model 3 interior is highly polarizing; you either love it or hate it. That will help carve out a niche even if all else is equal

- but most importantly, it's all about the batteries. Audi had to scale back e-tron production for 2019 due to battery supply issues; what's going to happen when the big carmakers need several orders of magnitude more batteries? Tesla has their own battery factory. OTOH, there are a LOT of chinese battery factories being built right now, we may see battery prices fall through the floor if they are overbuilding. Anybody who's watched the DRAM market over the past few decades knows what happens when you need really expensive factories to build a commodity...

1: https://electrek.co/2019/02/21/tesla-efficiency-range-test-a...

2: https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/audi-revises-production...

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by neuronic on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:22AM (#20264401)
Also from your source:

> As for Audi, I think that they are intentionally giving up their efficiency in order to protect the battery pack and get a higher charge rate.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by zaroth on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:26PM (#20267460)
That statement makes no sense. Efficiency is a measure of energy required to move the vehicle a certain distance, as in Wh/mi.

Range is battery capacity divided by efficiency. You can give up range to protect the battery, by limiting the charging capacity or the discharge depth, but you cannot give up efficiency.

There are likely a multitude of factors from motors, to drivetrain, to drag, to gross weight which contribute to Audi’s lower efficiency e-Tron. They have a fairly large battery, although smaller capacity than Tesla’s largest, but only get ~200mi of range out of it. Their efficiency and range is lower than the 2012 Model S. This is one area where Tesla has an indisputable technical lead.

You could argue, for example, that Audi sacrifices efficiency to have lower interior noise levels, or that they had a body design with higher drag they weren’t willing to compromise. But drag and weight alone don’t fully account for the large efficiency difference.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by woodandsteel on Monday June 24, 2019 @07:58PM (#20269801)
Batteries are key. Demand is expected to quadruple in the next 5 years, and battery manufacturers are going to struggle to keep up. As a consequence many auto manufacturers are going find their sales constrained by their battery supplies.

Tesla is at present way ahead of all the other auto companies here. That's because Musk realized a decade ago how important battery production is, and so Tesla and Panasonic built a battery factory that was about 10 times larger than any existing one. But who knows what the future will bring.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by fgonzag on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:36PM (#20270690)
No reason why other auto mfgs (even as a consorcium of sorts) couldn't build their own factory in partnership with Samsung, Sanyo, Sony, LG. If 18650s or 21700s are truly the future, capital will follow. I don't think Tesla's lead here is as insurmountable (or even as large) as people are making it out to be.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by benj111 on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:38PM (#20265409)
Yeah batteries are a big if. They could just become commodity items where Tesla doesn't have the scale to compete and the factories just become mill stones. On the other hand, they could be a major competitive advantage.

I'm not convinced their superior efficiency is an unbridgeable moat either.

My biggest concern is their, and their CEOs approach to certain things, destroying goodwill to the point they cease being the tech darling. If you want to compete with BMW or Mercedes, you need the brand name and the engineering.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by HeadsUpHigh on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:31PM (#20268132)
No tech moat lasts for long. The battery part might be just enough to bridge the gap until they have the scale to compete in price.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by aaomidi on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:53AM (#20264113)
Thing with Tesla is they have a few stuff they do better than others.

I hate the experience of buying a car. I hate going to a dealership. I hate haggling. I hate having to say no to every crap they want to sell me.

I think Tesla is a breath of fresh air in the car industry, and I think they're going to continue trying to do things differently than everyone else. We'll see how that spans out in the future, and if they're going to keep being able to fix these issues we've just come to accept with the traditional car industry.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by rootusrootus on Monday June 24, 2019 @05:43PM (#20268820)
I just recently shopped at a Tesla store. They weren't high pressure, but they were still definitely car salesmen. I got callbacks, I got attempts to dissuade me from waiting for a Model Y, etc. There are other dealers with a very similar style, not everyone is like a typical Chevy dealer.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by aaomidi on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @05:14PM (#20279027)
Maybe they've changed, they used to not get commission so they didn't care.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by somerandomness on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:14PM (#20265077)
Actually you can still haggle at the tesla store for in stock models. Otherwise you pay MSRP.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by revscat on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:11AM (#20264305)
> Once big auto moves to EVs, what will happen to Tesla?

I am very skeptical that this is ever going to happen, at least in any meaningful way. It's been pretty well established over the past couple of decades that corporations cannot steer away from their core profit centers, and thus far the auto manufacturers have done nothing to disprove this theory. So far, they have almost exclusively done nothing other than announcing future plans, but have not been able to pivot away from their core competencies.

There is a widespread belief that it is inevitable that Detroit, etc., will start producing EVs, and once they do so that Tesla will be crushed in very short order. I have seen no evidence to support this belief, despite Tesla having been in the market for over a decade.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by lorenzobr on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:27AM (#20264457)
I think this revolution will need to start from the bottom, new buyers need to realise that buying an ICE car does not make sense anymore, even if having EVs everywhere would only affect climate change by a small percentage, the benefits every city would get from them are far greater than keep filling roads with ICE vehicles.

Also governments at some point will start forcing their hand (and probably China will do that way before US given the current trend).

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by wil421 on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:50AM (#20264076)
I’ve always thought they’d be acquired if they fail or become a big enough threat. Usually downvoted for saying this. I think the Big 3 US/German makers figured EVs were a decade or two away after seeing Tesla and Leaf’s success they might be rethinking it.

Tesla’s software, engine tech, and battery production would be a nice addition to Big Autos stack.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by w8vY7ER on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:56AM (#20264152)
It would for sure be a boon for them to copy Tesla's homework in this fashion but let's not forget that the culture that fostered such breakthrough would likely suffocate and die in that post-acquisition environment. For a group whose stated mission is to accelerate the adoption of sustainable energy, I see this outcome to be unlikely. However much it might help those entrenched entities save face and present a "Hello, fellow EV makers!" facade.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by wil421 on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:49PM (#20265555)
Big companies acquire for the product not the innovation. Smart big companies will even leave the entity alone as not to hamper innovation. Most of the time they absolutely kill innovation as seen with Google and a couple innovate/grow by acquisition FinTech MegaCorps I worked at.

I’ve seen a few teams or line of businesses rally “Let’s get back our unique culture” after the merge. Not gonna happen if MegaCorp bought you. Everyone else already cashed out or left.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by WorldMaker on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:09PM (#20265823)
Elon Musk wouldn't have had the capital to bank Tesla in the first place if he ignored potential exits outright simply for principal's sake.

Not to mention that that sort of acquisition could be seen as "mission accomplished" given the right M&A voodoo or PR spin.

Tesla isn't immune to capitalism and is itself a product of it.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by SEJeff on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:44AM (#20264006)
Will big auto magically have a network to charge on, or a lot of patents on it? Tesla famously "open sourced" some of their patents, on electric drivetrain, but they also didn't open source their battery chemistry patents or a lot of the other EV related patents.

Also keep in mind if you look at the new electric vehicles, there isn't a one out today that beats the 2012 Model S in range (265 miles). Why is this? Because of the battery chemistry and drivetrain work that tesla has done which is leagues ahead of anyone. More vendors doing EVs might also make it cheaper to source some of the various components. I think more EVs is a net good for Tesla honestly as it pushes them more into the mainstream.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by treis on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:15AM (#20264336)
>Why is this? Because of the battery chemistry and drivetrain work that tesla has done which is leagues ahead of anyone.

I doubt that. It's much more likely because something like the Leaf is nearly half the cost of a Tesla model S and are made at a profit. At one point Tesla had a big lead, but Nissan has been making hte Leaf for nearly a decade now. It's unlikely that any significant gap is there because of technology reasons.