Maybe he didn't mean that the title is irrelevant from a SEO perspective (I don't think he meant that, it's hardly a closely guarded secret).
Maybe he doesn't think people tend to google for "breaking news" much.
Maybe he meant that ranking is great, but what if people don't click your jabberwocky title because it's confusing.
Just sayin'.
And, yes, you can't show up in search results (most often) unless you have SEO-optimized title tags. I would recommend serving up a specific SEO-title tag, and then another, closely related article title on the page itself - at least as it comes to news pieces.
And the other hand, I'd agree that it is in companies best interest to have the title tags short enough to get their brand in there - because brand relevancy helps CTR substantially. When CTR goes up, ranking may increase since Google is looking at these things in their algo. Then you get more clicks, views and links, and it starts a downhill, positive domino effect for your website.
SEOMofo has a great tool for making sure you don't breach Google's title tag/meta description character limit in the SERPs:
http://www.seomofo.com/snippet-optimizer.html