News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet is made out of meat by ars on Monday December 20, 2010 @06:13PM (#2026163)
"....cracking a problem that's basically tractable by human intelligence, if human intelligence could work on it for a few centuries."

This is a very common fallacy: assuming you can trade time for quality. i.e. every hard problem is solvable assuming you spend enough time on it (even infinite).

This is not true. Some problems are not solvable by some people no matter how long they spend on it.

That's the difference between genius and non genius, a genius can solve problems that others simply can't.

Just because you make an AI faster does not mean it can solve the problem. Some problems will be beyond the ability of the AI no matter how long it works on it.

Re:The Internet is made out of meat by gjm11 on Monday December 20, 2010 @06:57PM (#2026299)
I think you need to go back and read what he actually wrote, because he very explicitly doesn't make the mistake you're talking about. (You might have guessed that from the fact that he bothers to say "a problem that's basically tractable by human intelligence ..." rather than, say, "any problem".)

For instance, just a paragraph or two later than the bit you quoted: "If such higher types of intelligence can exist, and if a human-equivalent intelligence can build an AI that runs one of them — which is an open question".

Re:The Internet is made out of meat by ars on Monday December 20, 2010 @07:58PM (#2026457)
I was speaking in more general terms, (and that was an excellent quote to use). My post was about the singularity in general not this article specifically.

BTW: The idea of a Spamularity is hilarious! Especially since I don't believe in the singularity.