News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by pessimizer on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:57PM (#20259721)
> (This becomes a question of fact because particular facts matter. If the Godfather leans in and says the line you gave, for instance, to one of his loyal henchmen, the law should be able to punish him.)

That pretty much means that by calling someone a "godfather" I can prosecute them for things that normally wouldn't be a crime. What if I call someone a "terrorist," or a government a "regime"?

Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by michaelt on Monday June 24, 2019 @06:00AM (#20261887)
If one actor threatens to kill another on stage as part of a play, then says exactly the same words in the same tone to the same person off stage, the former threat isn't real and the latter case is real.

That's because the threat isn't just the words; it's also a question of intent - and in the absence of time-travelling MRI machines to objectively observe people's thoughts in the past, inferring the intent from context we can observe.

Of course, you could argue that having laws that depend on people's only-indirectly-observable mental state is a bad idea - that announcing your intention to blow up an airport should either always be legal, or never be legal. If you're interested in such questions, you might enjoy reading about the Twitter Joke Trial [1] over one such incident.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial

Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by leftyted on Sunday June 23, 2019 @11:17PM (#20260190)
No one said said "calls" until your post...

I think the point is well made - the jury has to decide what "I can't help you" means, and it means different things depending on who says it. This is the nature of human communication and we can't escape from it.

Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by brownbat on Monday July 01, 2019 @11:47PM (#20331976)
To clarify further, generally past convictions are inadmissible, because you don't want to bias a jury about the facts of the specific case.

"This guy murdered three other people!" is no proof that he murdered this particular person.

Because of those rules, calling someone a "godfather" in court doesn't so much get you a prosecution as it gets you an objection and mistrial.

So I used a lazy example to illustrate the point.

But this brings up another key point -- most of criminal procedure can be summed up by "you can't use irrelevant statements to prejudice the hell out of the jury."

All in all a pretty good rule.

Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by mindslight on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:31PM (#20259872)
> What if I call someone a "terrorist," or a government a "regime"?

Apparently you can push a lot of people into believing a prosecution is not purely political.

Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by reallydude on Monday June 24, 2019 @04:24PM (#20268056)
Historically, that has been the modus operandi since, at least, the Truman Doctrine.