News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion c... by mindslight on Sunday June 23, 2019 @08:37PM (#20259647)
I think it's an easy line to draw - it just looks difficult because it has been repeatedly stretched to catch one "bad guy" or another.

The example under discussion can be straightforwardly applied to the topic of software exploits. By posting a proof of concept to a mailing list, one knows that previously obscure information will then be in the hands of ne'er do wells. The motivation even includes foreseeing the exploit being used, pressuring the vendor/sysadmins into fixing it. Yet we are all safer when exploits are shared publicly so that they can be patched, rather than kept in obscurity.

Providing general information, even to someone who will use it for abuse, should be protected speech. "Ammonium nitrate plus Diesel" or "Just Google Casio F-91W and thank me later" are definitively in that territory. A weaker standard is begging for selective persecution, just as we see here.

There are no comments on this comment yet.