News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by jerf on Monday December 20, 2010 @03:51PM (#2025727)
"the trick is to figure out how to use natural lighting for a majority of the input."

No, that really is impossible. Mother Nature's little growers are optimized for the amount of sunlight they receive on flat ground, and by trying to stack farms on top of each other you utterly inevitably mathematically reduce the amount of sunlight each floor can get to substantially less than that, because the floors occlude each other, except the top floor. To the extent that people fail to take that into account they really are failing at physics badly and Monbiot is correct to criticize them.

I think under the right circumstances and with plausible technological development this can make sense, but he's absolutely correct that doing it with current technology is completely infeasible and useless. My position is actually not what he is criticizing, and I'm still open to the possibility that while the future may look different, the actual best solution is something not yet evident. We may also simply reduce the costs of transportation such that growing something 1000 miles away simply isn't that big a deal ecologically. (We really, really, really need cheap energy, cheap in all senses of the term, ecologically as well as economically. And there are feasible possibilities.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.