News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by Causality1 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @03:40AM (#20253799)
As far as I know ICBMs are still unstoppable once out of the boost phase and are moving at mach 20 by the time they leave the territory of the launching nation. The good news is that hypersonic missiles don't put us in any more danger than we're already in. The bad news is that despite being worthless we'll probably still spend a couple trillion dollars on them.
Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by thunderbird120 on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:35AM (#20253970)
This is generally incorrect in several different ways. ICBMs are not invulnerable after their boost phase and ballistic missile defense continues to improve rapidly. The U.S. operates a small number of mid-course interceptors as part of the GMD system[1] to defend against small scale attacks from states such as North Korea. The low number of interceptors does not upset the balance of power with any larger nuclear states but that may change in the near future. The U.S. has been pursuing a new kill vehicle for its interceptors to replace the current EKV[2]. The MOKV was based on an earlier program to put multiple kill vehicles on a single rocket[3]. This would allow for a single rocket to potentially intercept up to 6 incoming warheads. What's more, this interceptor could be fitted to the SM-3 anti-ballistic missile missile used by the navy, massively increasing the total number of possible interceptors. Hypersonic missiles do not follow a predictable trajectory and fly much lower than ballistic missiles making their detection and engagement extremely difficult. Detection is actually the larger of the two issues. From the time a nuclear armed hypersonic missile is detected to the time it impacts could be fewer than 5 minutes. Far far less than the ~30 minutes of warning you get for ballistic missiles. This timeframe is too short for a proper chain of command and massively increases the risk of mistakes being made. It also incentivizes first strikes. Unfortunately, any nation that does not have this capability is at a massive disadvantage when confronted by a nation that does. Even if not used for nuclear strikes, hypersonics have the ability to destroy key, heavily defended targets with essentially no notice. This will likely make them extremely important for future engagements, especially naval ones. The U.S. has a large and very well defended navy which is key to its military strategy. China and Russia's focus on hypersonics is no coincidence.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-Based_Midcourse_Defense

[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exoatmospheric_Kill_Vehicle

[3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_Kill_Vehicle

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by garmaine on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:17AM (#20253894)
Actually no, there is lots of tech to stop ICBMs, in launch, orbital and re-entry phase.

Hypersonic flight basically avoids all the weaknesses exploited by this older anti-ICBM tech.

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by gruez on Sunday June 23, 2019 @04:40AM (#20253981)
>Actually no, there is lots of tech to stop ICBMs, in launch, orbital and re-entry phase.

what's the success rate on those? afaik they're irrelevant, at least to russia/us because you can evade them by simply launching enough missiles (you only need a few missiles to take out all major population centers).

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by chipsa on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:39AM (#20254564)
The problem is launching enough missiles. Interceptors are expensive to develop, but cheap to make more of, and have relatively low cost of command and control (it doesn't matter if one gets launched by accident, right now). ICBMs are expensive to develop, expensive to make more of, and are expensive for command and control (because if one gets launched by accident, the world ends). So it's always going to be cheaper to make more interceptors than ICBMs.

But beyond that, interceptors make the entire targeting situation more complex. If you've got 1000 warheads, and no defenses, you can hit 1000 targets (not actually true, because you have a certain amount of failure rate, but anyway). If you're facing 10 interceptors, and some of your targets must be destroyed, then you have to launch enough warheads at each target that must be destroyed to still go through even if all of them are intercepted. So now you have ~90 must destroy targets you can actually hit with your 1000 warheads, even though you're only facing 10 interceptors. Those 10 interceptors have effectively negated 900 enemy warheads.

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by gruez on Sunday June 23, 2019 @09:03AM (#20255200)
>So it's always going to be cheaper to make more interceptors than ICBMs.

What's the source for this? Because I've also heard the opposite. Also, given that interceptors have to travel faster and more accurate than warhead ICBMs, you'd think they're more expensive to develop and have a higher unit cost.

>Those 10 interceptors have effectively negated 900 enemy warheads.

* The calculation you presented only really makes sense for very high intercept success rates. If the intercept rate is (conservatively) 80%, if the enemy sends 10 missiles, and you use all 10 interceptors on each, there's still a 91% chance of at least one missile coming through (1-0.8^10). The odds get better if you have double the number of interceptors (34%), but it's still unacceptably high. You'd need overwhelmingly more interceptors.

* I doubt there's 90 "must destroy" targets. If you spend all your interceptors protecting one target, even if that survives, your country is still utterly devastated that there's 0 hope of a counter attack. Does it really matter that washington, DC survived but the rest of the us is reduced to rubble?

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by chipsa on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:53PM (#20257852)
The price for aircraft and spacecraft is almost entirely related to how much it weighs. A missile that's 10x heavier is going to be 10x more expensive, generally speaking, for a given nation. GBI is approximately 21 tons. A Minuteman III is approximately 33 tons.

But you exclaim "The warheads are different!" It's hard to find the price, but an EKV is somewhere on the order of $20 million each. The W87-1 will cost somewhere between $8.6 and $14 billion for the entire program... not including the fissile pits that are being reused. This is still more per warhead than the EKV.

Yes, the interceptors have to be more accurate, but they also use entirely different guidance systems. They don't actually have to travel faster, because they just have to be in the same place at the same time as the target, and the target can't really do anything to stop them.

The problem with your statistical approach is that there's a chance that the target survives. And these are defined as must destroy targets. Places like launch control centers for ICBMs, Cheyenne Mountain for command control. Places you need to destroy to avoid them turning your own cities into self-lit parking lots. Because you aren't going to start a nuclear war to have a Pyrrhic victory.

Because the point of the US nuclear deterrent is to turn you into a self-lit parking lot, on demand, in thirty minutes or less. And by making sure we can do that, we keep other countries from thinking that they can start using WMDs. Does it really matter that you destroyed Washington DC if you no longer have a country? The biggest advantage of interceptors is not that you saved a city that was targeted. Rather, you made the opposition make a choice on what would actually get targeted. A city blown up by 3 nukes isn't much different from one blown up by 1, but it's significantly different from a city blown up by zero.

Example: back when the UK used V-bombers, they had 200 warheads targeted across the USSR. As Soviet defenses got better, the number of targets being hit was reduced. By the end of the Polaris program, all of the UK's warheads were targeted on Moscow.

And I'd be surprised if there's only 90 must destroy targets in the US. Not that Russia has 1000 warheads, but the US also doesn't have 10 interceptors, because it was example numbers to make the math easy.

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by garmaine on Sunday June 23, 2019 @02:29PM (#20257672)
Nukes are expensive.
Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by garmaine on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:08AM (#20254085)
Classified.

But the story of nuclear war is a bit more complicated than that. Sadly, city destruction doesn't usually fall into core considerations of win/loss.

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by oAlbe on Sunday June 23, 2019 @05:54AM (#20254320)
> Sadly, city destruction doesn't usually fall into core considerations of win/loss.

What does? Acts of occupation?

Re:Hypersonic Missiles Are Unstoppable by chipsa on Sunday June 23, 2019 @06:43AM (#20254586)
Destroying their ability or willingness to make war. Doesn't need to be occupation, but if they can still fight, you haven't won yet. And destroying cities usually doesn't do much for stopping them from fighting. It mostly just makes them want to fight harder.

The US lost the Vietnam War because we lost the willingness to fight. We can't effectively end the Afghanistan war because we can neither keep them from fighting, nor keep them from wanting to fight.