I completely missed the Droid Pro, which does dilute my argument a bit.
But: your statement that all Android phones look the same would support the idea that hardware could be a differentiator. Nokia has a long history of shipping many different kinds of hardware to many different customer segments. Android devices seem to have some trouble breaking out of the high-end segments where they are competing pretty directly with iPhone. The lower end Android devices also feel cheap. A lower-end Nokia never felt cheap.
All these things are exciting to Engadget and r/Android but are almost irrelevant to consumers and confusing to boot. If I had to pick an Android phone today, I would have no idea how to do it. So I stick to my current phone and wait for real game-changers to appear.