News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by michaelchisari on Monday December 20, 2010 @10:53AM (#2024637)
This was pointed out in the previous thread, but I'd like to remind people that the photos of gorgeous, 100-story spires in the heart of Manhattan are pure pipe dreams by architects and designers.

However, if you look at vertical farming as a series of low-rise greenhouse warehouses ringing a city, like a lightly stacked up Thanet Earth, then I think there's a strong case for them.

http://www.thanetearth.com/

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by Retric on Monday December 20, 2010 @11:16AM (#2024719)
The only way vertical farming becomes reasonable is with cheap energy, and high food costs.

Cattle actually come close to this because they don't need sunlight to grow so you can have multi story feed fed cattle farms. However, it's still cheaper to use more land than to build multi story cattle farms.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by rbranson on Monday December 20, 2010 @12:32PM (#2025053)
The bottom line is that it's a cute futuristic fantasy. We need to get PEOPLE off of the farm land and into vertical buildings FIRST. There are millions of acres of arable land totally wasted by people's unused front lawns and abandoned parking lots. We have to protect this precious land and not just let developers sprawl all over it in the name of cheap, discardable pseudo-communities.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by anamax on Monday December 20, 2010 @04:49PM (#2025897)
> We need to get PEOPLE off of the farm land and into vertical buildings FIRST. There are millions of acres of arable land totally wasted by people's unused front lawns and abandoned parking lots. We have to protect this precious land and not just let developers sprawl all over it in the name of cheap, discardable pseudo-communities.

Why?

While suburbia may offend you, replacing suburbia with hive-living wouldn't significantly increase the amount of arable land in use.

The places that have food shortages have them because of bad governance, which hive-living won't fix.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by michaelchisari on Monday December 20, 2010 @05:25PM (#2026015)
The ecological benefits of urban density are much greater than you give it credit for. And I think a characterization of "hive-living" doesn't nearly do justice to the cultural, social, and economic benefits of a vibrant city.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by anamax on Monday December 20, 2010 @10:40PM (#2026847)
> The ecological benefits of urban density are much greater than you give it credit for.

And you know this, how? Let me suggest that you probably overstate the costs of suburbia.

> And I think a characterization of "hive-living" doesn't nearly do justice to the cultural, social, and economic benefits of a vibrant city.

You're assuming that everyone values the things that you do in much the same way. That may be true of the other folks in your tribe, but extrapolating universality from that demonstrates my point.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by iron_ball on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @07:50AM (#2027611)
Calling it a "hive" and city dwellers a "tribe" has strong negative connotations you cannot be unaware of. Be open-minded when calling for openmindedness.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by anamax on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:31AM (#2028285)
There's nothing negative about "tribe".

As far as "hive" goes, it's apt. It's accurate and the connotations point out the other side of the claimed advantages.

> Be open-minded when calling for openmindedness.

I'm not calling for openmindedness. I'm pointing out cherry-picking, and a couple of other problems.

I don't care where other people choose to live. However, if they're going to argue that their choice is superior, I think that it's fair to see if their argument makes sense. What part of that do you disagree with?

Which reminds me - I'm certain that I'll see you make the same complaints when an urbanist commits my sins, right?

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by iron_ball on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:32PM (#2030357)
Of course. I grew up in the suburbs and I liked it there. I appreciate your vote of confidence.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by nradov on Monday December 20, 2010 @05:53PM (#2026092)
We don't need to do anything of the sort. If that was a real problem then prices for agricultural land would be higher. Back during WWII, suburbanites turned their lawns into "victory gardens" and grew vegetables. It's easy enough to do the same thing again if it ever becomes necessary.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by mburns on Monday December 20, 2010 @08:45PM (#2026558)
production yield of a victory garden is still vastly smaller than a scaled-up effort. You can't avoid the economies of scale. Europe has long used stacked housing (people live in 'flats', etc) in place of a discrete hunk of land with their own castle to sit upon.

10 people can work together and use 10 plots of land more efficiently than 10 individuals using 1 plot of land each. We just don't have a land shortage to the point of making availability an issue.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by elblanco on Monday December 20, 2010 @12:09PM (#2024953)
> The only way vertical farming becomes reasonable is with cheap energy, and high food costs

I'd argue it'd only become tenable with high land costs. The cheaper energy is, the less sense vertical farming becomes since it makes the transport costs from far away, cheap-land areas even lower. If real-estate in and out of a city are roughly the same (no cheap pasture land!), then the farm can be more or less any location, that includes in a city. But for that to happen, would probably imply some kind of Judge Dredd continent swallowing city first.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by joe_the_user on Monday December 20, 2010 @12:35PM (#2025065)
Extremely high energy costs combined with low building costs might also make this feasible.

The scenario for this would be if the green houses grew themselves... which isn't utterly unimaginable.

Consider a red-wood sized tree/vine that gave high-protein fruit. Perhaps it would use just a bit of human-built scaffolding.

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by joe_the_user on Monday December 20, 2010 @12:50PM (#2025101)
The only way cattle are "eco-friendly" is in the cattle+marginal land equation.

Even modern feedlots only takes cattle after they've spent a while grazing and quality of the resulting meat has been criticized. Cattle that spent all of it's life indoors could plausibly have many more problems than one see for today's meat.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feedlot

Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by michaelchisari on Monday December 20, 2010 @11:22AM (#2024740)
Thanet Earth has already shown that indoor agriculture is competitive, and as we run out of arable land, and as shipping costs increase, it becomes more so.
Re:Vertical farming: Does it really stack up? by Retric on Monday December 20, 2010 @11:40AM (#2024811)
Greenhouses are competitive. Greenhouses with supplemental lighting can be competitive when growing specific plants. Multi story agriculture is only going to take off after most Greenhouses use supplemental lighting.