Re:Plain and simple: Net neutrality is hypocrisy
by nazgulnarsil on Monday December 20, 2010 @07:47AM
(#2024109)
I don't think net neutrality legislation means what you think it means.
government regulation with regards to ISP's is broken, thus stifling the competition that would ensure far more robust net neutrality than any legislated version.
you don't stop monopolies from abusing their powers by legislating that they play fair. you take away the governmental protections that allow them to have a monopoly and let the market consume them when they refuse to change their shitty business practices.
Re:Plain and simple: Net neutrality is hypocrisy
by _stephan on Monday December 20, 2010 @08:27AM
(#2024203)
> you take away the governmental protections that allow them to have a monopoly and let the market consume them when they refuse to change their shitty business practices.
How is that supposed to work? Have you ever heard of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly
Re:Plain and simple: Net neutrality is hypocrisy
by nazgulnarsil on Monday December 20, 2010 @09:06AM
(#2024284)
no examples exist. the wikipedia example is terrible. epidemics were caused by something that had never existed up until that point? (water network) and because profit margins were too low? so you're going to tell me that a lack of running water caused widespread DEATH AND PESTILENCE and people still were going "nah, I think I'll wait for those water bills to drop some more"?
Re:Plain and simple: Net neutrality is hypocrisy
by _stephan on Monday December 20, 2010 @09:54AM
(#2024442)
My point was that in certain markets unregulated competition will naturally lead to a monopoly. The technical term for this in microeconomics is "natural monopoly", and the explanation at the beginning of the Wikipedia article is actually pretty good.
Without regulation monopolists can prevent the market entry of competitors and can extract excessive profits from consumers, to the detriment of society as a whole.
Re:Plain and simple: Net neutrality is hypocrisy
by nazgulnarsil on Monday December 20, 2010 @09:29PM
(#2026661)
again please point to a single example of this happening ever.
No. There's regulation and there's regulation. Net neutrality is the concept that network providers should not privilege some kinds of content over others - i.e. that all packets are created equal.