News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by Animats on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @02:24PM (#20225798)
Yes, that's a well-known story. Probably the best demo of all time.

How did Charles Parsons get away with it? He was a Peer of the Realm, in an era when only the House of Lords could try a peer. The story is that when the Admiralty sent some people over to his offices to chew him out, the Prussian naval attache was just leaving. The Admiralty then decided they had better make a deal rather than let the Prussian Navy get ahead.

Parsons was originally shooting for 45 knots or so. The turbines had the power, but they couldn't couple it into the water effectively. No reduction gears, so the props turned too fast. Turbinia had three prop shafts with three props on each shaft, trying to keep the load per prop under control. If they applied too much power, they just bored a hole in the water. That's cavitation.

Transmissions for turbine ships are a big problem. It's one of those things that gets little public attention and is really hard to get right. High-precision double helical gears work, but are hard to make, and were hard to make through WWII. There was a fad for turboelectric drive, like a Diesel-electric locomotive, in the 1920s. No need for reduction gears. That idea comes and goes; the Zumwalt class destroyers are turboelectric drive.

Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by stcredzero on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @04:36PM (#20227082)
There was a fad for turboelectric drive, like a Diesel-electric locomotive, in the 1920s. No need for reduction gears. That idea comes and goes; the Zumwalt class destroyers are turboelectric drive.

Lately, I've been wondering about hybrid electric turbochargers. The batteries would be a lot of extra weight, but it might make sense for hybrid cars that have the batteries anyways. Shouldn't that yield turbocharging with very high boost, but zero lag?

Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @06:15PM (#20227902)
Formula 1 already does this. From what I can tell, it requires a really long shaft between the compressor and the expander sections of the turbo, for thermal reasons, so it's a very expensive piece of kit. Also, it requires that your typical driving scenario frequently dumps a lot of flow out the wastegate, which is known as "driving like an idiot" on normal roads.
Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by mark-r on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @05:07PM (#20227346)
Might work, but unnecessary - the electric motors coupled to the wheels directly already give you the equivalent of turbo. I have no problem squealing the tires on my Hybrid Camry.
Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday June 19, 2019 @06:19PM (#20227926)
I have no problem squealing the tires on my old french car with its formidable 1.6L naturally aspirated inline-four that produced 109 horespower when new. It's not a very telling metric.
Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by mark-r on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:51PM (#20238633)
My 1981 Renault couldn't even dream of squealing its tires.
Re:Turbinia – An Uninvited Guest (2014) by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 21, 2019 @07:12AM (#20241453)
So mine is a 2001 Peugeot, it's "old" but not "veteran". Probably it has twice the low-end torque of the equivalent 80s car, and 50% more power.

In the 80s French cars, 110 horsepower was "high performance" versions like the 205 GTI, which could definitely make some noise.