News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unhosted - Freedom from web 2.0's monopoly platforms by bbarthel on Sunday December 19, 2010 @02:28PM (#2022302)
I don't think I understand what they are proposing here. When I read this it sounds like a simple return to client applications. The workflow sounds like:

1) I go to the web to download the application.

2) Once I have the application I run it locally.

3) I encrypt and save the data back to "the cloud". Since I own the data, I can specify where to save it and the "web" becomes nothing more than distributed storage.

This is nothing I can't already do if I choose. We already have things like Silverlight applications, Java applications, Flash applications, etc. that all run client-side in the browser. Throw in ClickOnce deployment from Microsoft (which installs a .NET application directly to your computer by visiting a website and agreeing to the install), the linux app repositories, or even just the old "purchase and download" model, and I do not see how this proposal solves a technical problem we currently have - and if it is not a technical problem, then proposing a technical solution isn't going to solve it.

If I understand the intent, it is to prevent companies from owning the data that we create. Where the code executes does not seem to be relevant.

There are no comments on this comment yet.