Re:Boeing employee: I would not put my family on a Max plane
by codedokode on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @03:54PM
(#20217671)
There might be other differences. On the road, a lot depends on your style of driving, whether you are careful, but in case with a plane, you cannot do anything to make the flight safer.
Re:Boeing employee: I would not put my family on a Max plane
by cameldrv on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @04:44PM
(#20218203)
Yes, but on the other hand you can't do very much to make it more dangerous either. If you show up to your flight drunk, you're no more likely to crash.
Re:Boeing employee: I would not put my family on a Max plane
by snuxoll on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @03:28PM
(#20217344)
The most dangerous parts of flight are during takeoff and landing, something Boeing didn’t seem to accurately account for in the design of the 737 Max’s safety systems.
If you’re over 10K feet in the air there is some room for recovery procedures, but if you haven’t reached cruising altitude you have much less time before a plane finds itself impacting the ground.
Per-mile travelled isn’t an adequate standard to compare aircraft with other modes of transit when talking about safety.
Re:Boeing employee: I would not put my family on a Max plane
by matt-attack on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @05:31PM
(#20218660)
I think per hour of use would be a better metric.
The U.S. motor vehicle accident rate is about 1.2 fatalities per 100,000,000 vehicle miles travelled. Figure a car's average speed is 30mph so 1.2 fatalities per 3.3 million hours = 0.36 fatalities per million hours. Therefore on an hourly basis, the 737MAX is very roughly 5x more dangerous than driving. OTOH the 737MAX averages about 400mph, so per mile it's probably something like 2-3x safer.