Re:Ask HN: What's your "hair on fire" problem?
by user24 on Sunday December 19, 2010 @03:00PM
(#2022365)
> It looks to me like this is an issue rooted in friction between those folks who spend a great deal of time here and those folks who spend less time here. Those folks who are here a great deal see all the duplicate submissions and find them annoying
Yeah I think that's a lot to do with it. I've noticed time and time again with online communities that the longer you use it, the more likely you are to start complaining that it's not as good as it used to be. It happens everywhere, and the problem is almost invariably you not it.
It looks to me like this is an issue rooted in friction between those folks who spend a great deal of time here and those folks who spend less time here. Those folks who are here a great deal see all the duplicate submissions and find them annoying -- "BTDT, got the t-shirt, can we puhleez move on??". Those folks who spend less time here see it as a new submission or submit it without having any idea it was previously submitted. It sounds to me a little like the running battle you see on some email lists between folks who get digest (and have hissy fits about people not trimming replies) and folks who get individual emails (and feel that trimming replies is too time consuming and loses too much context, thus hurts communication).
I'm sorry you are frustrated by this. And I'm sorry if this issue contributes to "evaporative cooling" of this site (ie by you and others leaving -- my general impression is that you are a significant contributor and that the folks most annoyed by duplicates are usually also important, valued members). But I don't think that vilifying individuals who have posted something in good faith is a constructive solution to a systemic problem.
Please do let us know if you come up with something that might effectively address this issue.
Peace. Thanks for all you have contributed. I imagine many people here will miss you if you leave.