Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by epi0Bauqu on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:48AM
(#202125)
That's exactly the problem I am describing. They are making their own portraits, but they aren't sticking to their usernames, at least for me. A visual icon would help. It could be small, 25x25 as someone suggested.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by stcredzero on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:19AM
(#202182)
Maybe you could write a Greasemonkey script? You could have randomly generated avatars like Miis. Then you could also assign an image for specific posters that you feel are better indicative of their personalities.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by GHFigs on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:35AM
(#202213)
That's basically what Gravatar has recently adopted (http://blog.gravatar.com/2008/04/22/identicons-monsterids-an...) for non-users, and it is equal parts tacky and useful.
I'm not sold on the idea of something like this here, but even a very small icon (like 16x16 or smaller--very small) or bullet of color would would make threads easier to keep track of.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by epi0Bauqu on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:20AM
(#202185)
Where would you get the images? Just generate them randomly?
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by petercooper on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:35AM
(#202215)
Identicons: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identicon
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by rplevy on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @02:07PM
(#202392)
The only problem with identicons I have seen is that the algorithm used causes a majority of them to look like swastikas. But that seems like an easy thing to fix. Most of the identicons are quite pretty (including a large number of swastikas), but most people still associate swastikas with naziism.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by petercooper on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @02:58PM
(#202460)
Swastikas aside, I don't personally feel they're a good solution. They can be useful in semi-anonymous situations to determine one person from another (or an impostor posing as someone else), but I don't find them even vaguely recognizable from one another in the most case. They're very easily confusable.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by bct on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @03:32PM
(#202508)
Not only did the Nazis ruin an ancient symbol, they ruined rotational symmetry.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by stcredzero on Thursday May 29, 2008 @03:04AM
(#203089)
And they ruined a bunch of debates on the Internet!
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by Tichy on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @04:21PM
(#202573)
I think the human brain is optimized for recognizing faces. Those geometric variations of identicon don't look different enough in my opinion. I like the general idea, though.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by jcl on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:40AM
(#202224)
If the purpose is -- as you say -- to "start associating usernames more with their set of comments", then random images should suffice. If the purpose is to have a visual item of personal expression added to each post, I suppose you'd need each person to choose one for themselves.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by epi0Bauqu on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:45AM
(#202230)
Well, a random image may not suffice for that purpose. I just don't know. Maybe for it to work, it has to be some sort of recognizable image. But random images would at least be worth a shot.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by Alex3917 on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:53AM
(#202136)
Even if you were to add pictures, the place to do it would be on the user's profile page and not next to the posts.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by epi0Bauqu on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:56AM
(#202142)
I disagree, but that would certainly be a good start. I disagree because then I would have to click each time to see it, and that is an extra step. With some small icon on the page, I'd develop the history in an osmosis-like manner.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by kashif on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:30AM
(#202205)
I agree. I think we can all give links to our blogs, or make a community on facebook. Actually, I am just going to do that and submit a link for those who are interested.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by kashif on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:47AM
(#202236)
Here is a group for facebook.
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=14841858677
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by eru on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @05:45PM
(#202668)
I won't succumb to facebook anytime, soon. Sorry.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by andreyf on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:55AM
(#202139)
25x25 is pretty big. I think it would be clever to make it 15x15 or 10x10...
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by jgrahamc on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:14AM
(#202174)
How about just 1x1? Using the standard RGB color space there are 16,777,216. I doubt HN will have that many users so everyone gets their own color :-)
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by boredguy8 on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:18AM
(#202180)
Your design is not future-proof.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by mrtron on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:21AM
(#202188)
Sure it is, just add another pixel :)
"Look at that 3 pixel noob..."
You could use the user's top bar preferences!
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by apgwoz on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @01:04PM
(#202320)
only the elite have the privilege of changing the topbar color.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by eru on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @05:44PM
(#202667)
Only the elite deserves their very own pixel.
(I recently joined the elite - that's why I'm smug.)
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by boredguy8 on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @11:17AM
(#202179)
...or 10 x 1. Even with only 32 colors per pixel, that's over a quadrillion color combinations.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by noahlt on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:56AM
(#202141)
I think pg's "portrait" was a metaphor.
Re:The case for pictures next to usernames on Hacker News
by epi0Bauqu on Wednesday May 28, 2008 @10:56AM
(#202143)
Of course it was a metaphor, and I continued it. I wasn't being literal. I'm saying if you did look at the set of comments of a person, you would see the "portrait." But that isn't happening, since at least in my mind, over time that set of comments isn't being associated with that username.