News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minnesota court decision means doctors can be sued by pat... by DanBC on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:47PM (#20205522)
I'm amazed this need to go to supreme court because it seems obvious to me that you are responsible if you decline to admit someone based on a mini-dx you've made.

> It raises at least three questions worthy of extensive public debate.

The writer lists those 3 questions as

> (1) Who authorized Fairview hospitalists to deny admission to patients they haven’t examined?

> (2) Since when is diabetes a reasonable explanation of fever, chills and an elevated white-blood-cell count?

> (3) What role did financial incentives and micromanagement of doctors play in inducing Drs. Dinter and Baldwin to make such a serious error?

A more interesting question would be "does suing doctors prevent medical error or negligence?" The answer is probably no. Here's a rough guide of what should happen in England (although it often doesn't happen like this). https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/just-culture-guide/

That guide includes questions like "was there intent to cause harm?", "were there protocols in place?", "were those protocols followed?"

> After hearing Simon’s summary of Warren’s symptoms, Dr. Dinter declared her symptoms were due to “a diabetes that’s out of control” [...] Rather than challenge Dinter’s flaky diagnosis, Simon asked him again to admit Warren. Dinter replied, “To what end?” (pp. 4-5) Simon got the message: Dinter had made up his mind he would not admit this patient, and he was not interested in further discussion.

An important set of questions to ask are:

1) Could it be sepsis?

2) Why isn't it sepsis?

3) What things make it this other dx and not sepsis?

There a bunch of information about how people perceived as lower status (nurses v doctors in this case) can challenge the other person in a way that causes a change in behaviour, rather than just a stubborn "digging the heels in response".

Nurses play a crucial role in speaking up for patient safety.

Probe: "I don't understand why ...?"

Alert: "I am concerned that ..."

Challenge: "This risks harm because ..."

Emergency: "Stop. We need to get advice before we continue."

Sadly, it looks like this nurse did try to challenge and was let down by other doctors.

Re:Minnesota court decision means doctors can be sued by pat... by man2525 on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:46PM (#20206118)
From the legal documents I skimmed, it looks like the state hospital association, state medical association, and american medical association were on the side of the defense. The SC chief justice and an associate justice dissented. I mentioned this to a friend who is a doctor, and he doesn't believe the AMA would take a position.

Edit: Nevermind. The AMA's interest is that it is against abusive legislation against physicians. They felt the facts were recited more favorably to the prosecution.