News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by _delirium on Saturday December 18, 2010 @03:29PM (#2020202)
As an American PhD student currently finishing up and moving to a European faculty job, I was quite surprised at #2. Typical pay for a CS PhD student in the U.S. is somewhere in the $16k-24k range. In Denmark, it's $45k!

(I clearly did things backwards, because the opposite is true of faculty pay.)

Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by raphman on Saturday December 18, 2010 @08:43PM (#2020807)
However, duties of a PhD student vary a lot. I am not sure about Denmark but in Germany, CS PhD students usually work as full-time employees at the university.There is no grad school¹. You are expected to balance your PhD research (realistically, 25 % of your time), teaching (50%), and misc. obligations (20%).

¹ There are a few dedicated grad schools at some institutions. However, these are the exception, not the norm.

Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by InquilineKea on Saturday December 18, 2010 @06:04PM (#2020541)
How is the Canadian stipend? And do higher-paying countries tend to pay lower stipends?

Do schools in Scandinavia and the Netherlands even care if your only language is English?

Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by ndrarmst on Saturday December 18, 2010 @07:22PM (#2020683)
From what I've seen, the Canadian stipends range from a low of about $15k, for those on research assistantships (paid out of their supervisor's research budget) or on provincial scholarships, to a high of about $21k (NSERC or other tri-council federal scholarships). There are a limited number of higher-paying tri-council scholarships as well.

Some universities will top up a federal/provincial scholarship (Waterloo tops up by $10,000), and teaching assistantships are available as well. However, part-time work hours (TA or otherwise) are usually limited by the terms of the scholarship/assitantship, so there is a limit to how much a student can reasonably earn while doing a degree (NSERC limits to 10 hours worked/week, the expected hours for a TA).

Tuition is paid out of the student's stipend amount, though it's often quite a bit less than undergraduate tuition in CS and similar programs. My fee bill dropped in half when I finished my BASc and started an MASc.

Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by phamilton on Saturday December 18, 2010 @06:20PM (#2020576)
In my experience they do not. I've met quite a lot of masters degree students in Sweden that do not speak Swedish at all. Most are from African countries and South America.
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by Lewisham on Saturday December 18, 2010 @05:00PM (#2020422)
...although there is a cost of living aspect to factor in (not that that accounts for that large a difference, of course).
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by rbranson on Saturday December 18, 2010 @06:25PM (#2020584)
So Boston, Bay Area, NYC, etc are more expensive than Denmark? Almost all of the universities in the US where getting a PhD would be worth a damn are in high cost of living areas.
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by Lewisham on Saturday December 18, 2010 @09:53PM (#2020931)
Yes, pretty much. It's all relative. Food and commodities are much, much cheaper in the US than Europe.
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by _delirium on Sunday December 19, 2010 @05:32PM (#2022700)
Even housing to some extent, from what I can tell. The Bay Area ain't cheap, but rents aren't like London or Paris, either. (Well, maybe NYC rents are.)
Re:Tell HN: Doing a PhD is good by jlees on Saturday December 18, 2010 @04:58PM (#2020414)
The UK stipend is in line with the US one - it's not Europe-wide decent pay, that's for sure!