Nodding is the only thing dangerous about heroin addicts who have access to heroin, everything else is a symptom of prohibition. Additionally, long-term heroin addicts who have a consistent supply don't really nod much, or for long. It's the gaps in supply (of unadulterated drugs with a predictable purity) and the consequent simultaneous reduction of tolerance and increase in desperation that causes accidental overdoses and deep nodding.
Nodding is of course dangerous for drivers and operators of heavy machinery, but it should be treated like we treat any other sort of chronic seizure issue.
But, I am far out of my area of expertise to know anything about clinical depression.
Frankly, imho, this is often driven by politicians. They're fond of make campaign promises to solve Issue X. The problem is, they've gotten the problem wrong.
Unpopular opinion: I’m ok putting non-violent people in jail when they break the law. We need reform in the jails and prisons, not more lenient sentencing.
And because I’m sure it needs to be clarified, not every law breaker needs to go to jail immediately.
Your suggestion of reform is indeed necessary, but some of the things I suggested above would fall outside of what most people would consider "jail." We are stuck on this singular "solution", and why? It doesn't seem to be very effective.
- selling drugs to adults.
- adults buying drugs
- prostitution (either side)
If we simply legalized all drugs tomorrow I don’t think it would solve many problems. We have to also look at and treat the underlying cause of addiction and drug abuse.
The point is if you break the law the state should have the ability to force corrections.
I’m completely in support of reinventing what those corrections are.
If we're looking at addiction as a mental illness to be rehabilitated from, I would posit that forcibly housing them with a bunch of other mentally ill people, some of whom may be violent, would be traumatic enough to most people that it would more than negate the benefits of many rehabilitative interventions.
If locking up drug addicts in a room and telling them to sort it out doesn’t work maybe we should try a new form of rehab instead of just saying “well I guess rehab doesn’t work”.
Solutions to the housing, homeless and drug problem exist but the voters and politicians don't want them.
Can someone give their reason as to down voting this comment?
There have been numerous articles posted here as of late relating to loneliness, suicide rates, etc. What do you need to see the bigger picture? I don't understand why this is so difficult. I feel like there must be some ideology in the way here or maybe politics or cognitive dissonance. I mean you could have just ignored the comment if you were in ambivalent disagreement.
Having worked in social services for 14 years it has become clear to me that social support, ie healthy family structures, friends and coworkers, as well as having a meaningful reason to get out of bed in the morning are the most important factors when it comes to overcoming addiction. I'm not aware of much research regarding this aspect of treatment. All I can say to that is that I have a very paranoid and pessimistic view as to why.
I didn’t downvote the parent, but the idea that only unhappy people use drugs isn’t true. Maybe if you limit it to hard drugs or maybe if you limit to “abusing drugs”? I have no strong opinions.
Alcohol and marijuana are both drugs, plenty of happy people drink and smoke weed. On the other hand, plenty of opioid addicts started taking the drug legally because of a real pain and then got addicted.
Most famous is probably the Rat Park study: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park
Blaming the drugs is an easy out and probably is more pleasing to people coming from a puritan world view.
If you lock up the users, you’re just spending more money housing non violent offenders. If you lock up the sellers, someone else will take their place. Homeless drug addicts don’t fear jail, how could it be any worse than life on the street addicted to drugs?
I have no idea what the answer is, but I suspect it is a better social safety net where people think they have a fair shot in society where they don’t view drugs as an escape or have the mindset of having nothing to lose. I honestly haven’t thought about solutions that deeply.