Re:Researchers use Rowhammer bit flips to steal 2048-bit cry...
by walterbell on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:19AM
(#20195559)
> "TRR makes it more difficult to find bit flips," Kwong, the University of Michigan researcher, wrote in an email. "Not all DDR4 has TRR enabled, and implementations vary substantially by vendor, so it is difficult to pinpoint exactly how much safer TRR is against Rowhammer. TRR's susceptibility to RAMBleed is an open research question."
> Third I/O employees tested 12 varieties of DDR4 chips, and it didn't take long for eight of them to succumb to bitflipping. The first DIMM to fall was Crucial Ballistix Sport model manufactured by Micron. Ultimately, the researchers also carried out successful Rowhammer attacks against other Crucial- and Micron-branded DDR4 modules, as well as DIMMs from Geil. Interestingly, DIMMs from G.Skill were able to withstand the tests.
> Of the twelve memory modules we tested, eight showed bit flips during our 4-hour experiment. And of these eight failures, every memory module that failed at default settings was on DDR4 silicon manufactured by Micron. The Geil branded modules contained SK Hynix and the G.Skill modules contained Samsung silicon.
Samsung added TRR (Target Row Refresh) to their memory, see slide 15 of this 2014 presentation, http://aod.teletogether.com/sec/20140519/SAMSUNG_Investors_F....
From https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/03/once-...
> Third I/O employees tested 12 varieties of DDR4 chips, and it didn't take long for eight of them to succumb to bitflipping. The first DIMM to fall was Crucial Ballistix Sport model manufactured by Micron. Ultimately, the researchers also carried out successful Rowhammer attacks against other Crucial- and Micron-branded DDR4 modules, as well as DIMMs from Geil. Interestingly, DIMMs from G.Skill were able to withstand the tests.
From the linked 2016 paper, http://www.thirdio.com/rowhammer.pdf
> Of the twelve memory modules we tested, eight showed bit flips during our 4-hour experiment. And of these eight failures, every memory module that failed at default settings was on DDR4 silicon manufactured by Micron. The Geil branded modules contained SK Hynix and the G.Skill modules contained Samsung silicon.