Previously when software was sold at retail, consumers had no qualms paying for software.
So maybe you are right and the root problem are the business models and specifically the funding behind those models.
> Previously when software was sold at retail, consumers had no qualms paying for software.
When was this? I recall the warez, cracking and keygen scenes being huge years ago (before the rise of SaaS).
And there are many assumptions in your post that are not necessarily true:
1. Services could still be free to most users, with paid versions that provide more functionality.
2. Privacy invasion and advertising has a cost, that those very people worrying about food have to pay. They don't have to pay 2$/month for e-mail, but then will spend N$ for the expertly marketed toy/cereal their child is throwing a tantrum over, and their own purchasing choices will also be affected adversely - advertising works.
As for how society would decide it, I see consumer pressure as decisive, the more ethical handling of data becomes a selling point, the more financial incentives companies have to implement and market it. It's visible right now in how Apple positions itself against Google as the more privacy minded company with enough public appraisal to challenge, if not invalidate, your assumption.
As long as it's a voluntary business relationship, there's nothing to say. If your scale of preferences tells you that privacy is a more important factor than the service itself, then use the services that suit your demand, but don't prevent others from acting differently.
>If we as a society decide to limit how companies can collect and use our data...
Why? I don't have the right to decide for you. If you decide to get married, do I have the right to tell you how to proceed in your contractual relationship with your partner? As long as it is a voluntary contract and the individual rights of others are respected..., does the rest of society or the government have the right to decide or impose rules for you or your partner on how your association proceeds?
"Take it, leave it or shut up." If the concept of "privacy" is as important to society as it is to you, it will lead to an increase in demand and supply linked to services that incorporate greater privacy into their products. You don't need to do anything about it, but whatever you try to do in an arbitrary, subjective and coercive way, it will be objectively immoral and violent towards the rest of the people.
>Companies don't have a right to their business model. They have that right because we all have it, just as you have the right to plan your life but you don't have the right to plan someone else's life.
These are all voluntary business relationships. They're illegal because society has mostly agreed that there should be a limit to how much a transaction can extract from someone. That people, even at their most desperate, should still be protected.
And yes, the bounds here can be arbitrary. Selling organs is illegal while selling sperm and eggs is not. But ultimately, most everyone agrees that we should draw the line somewhere. The entire point of a society is a set of norms around how to interact with others.
That's completely ignoring network effects: I want to delete WhatsApp from my phone. But if I do so, it means I won't be taking part in everyday family life anymore.
If "society" requires services with a greater emphasis on privacy, they will be more in demand and will find their corresponding offer in the marketplace.
>Why we can't have privacy on the internet... Bullshit. We can have whatever we want, but if I demand something I must offer something in return, be it money, private data or unicorns. There is no such thing as a free coffee.
Ah yes, the classic refrain of “the free market will just fix everything” despite that, you know, not being the case time-and-time-again.
A huge number of products and services these days are “supply driven demand”, so consumers voting with your wallet is extremely limited in scope and power: you’re not being given a representative set of available options, you’re being given the choice between a few-often superficially different- options that companies are happy to provide. Coupled with the fact that many companies and the advertising industry as a whole has pushed a narrative of “just give up all your data, it’s fiiiinnne” means consumers aren’t informed or aware of all the options they could demand. Add in the fact that a huge number of people simply don’t have the luxury of shopping around for their preferred product at every opportunity.
> you're not being given a representative set of available options...
What would those options be? Who decides that? For me the market does, who should do it for you? What I'm saying is simple, if there are more people who demand services that respect their privacy, then the offer of those services will arise. If, for example, we are in an abstemious society no one will demand wine, then it is foolish to try to produce wine under those circumstances. It will only be profitable to produce wine there if the preferences of that society change.
>"just give up all your data, it's fiiiinnne" I don't know. It may or may not be fine, you decide for you and I decide for me. I'm not going to force you to make a decision you don't want and I hope you do the same.
Anyway, it's silly to say that we can't have privacy on the Internet. My position is that we can have the services we want, privacy, security, with whatever preponderant factor we want to have, but not for free. You will pay with money, with personal data or whatever the other party accepts as payment, but you will always pay. All this discussion takes place only in contexts where there are people who think they can access all kinds of things for "free", who have the right to dispose of someone else's work, capital, time or property as they please.
Whether we like it or not, the market currently tells us that, in general, access to certain services is more valuable than consumer privacy.
they probably discussed making people pay a small fee but I'm sure many web things died when they asked for money
Why does it follow that we should be okay with privacy intrusions?
Companies don't have a right to their business model. If we as a society decide to limit how companies can collect and use our data, and it forces some to start charging their users or go out of business, that's okay! Just because that's a sustainable way to run a business right now doesn't mean it should be.