News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by jakelazaroff on Saturday June 15, 2019 @04:32PM (#20191967)
> Every online service costs money to provide. [...] Since most people are unwilling to pay for online services, the way to cover these costs is by advertising to the users.

Why does it follow that we should be okay with privacy intrusions?

Companies don't have a right to their business model. If we as a society decide to limit how companies can collect and use our data, and it forces some to start charging their users or go out of business, that's okay! Just because that's a sustainable way to run a business right now doesn't mean it should be.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by cortesoft on Saturday June 15, 2019 @04:57PM (#20192101)
This is also based on the assumption that you can't have ads and privacy. We had ads for a long time without privacy invasion. Just have the ads match the content being viewed (instead of the person viewing the content)
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by MarkMc on Saturday June 15, 2019 @08:33PM (#20193084)
Can't you already do that using your browser's incognito mode?
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by inetknght on Sunday June 16, 2019 @12:25PM (#20196285)
Using browsers incognito mode does not eliminate privacy violations.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by josho on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:00PM (#20192116)
The reason why consumers are unwilling to pay for service is because VCs have funded companies ability to give away tremendous value to achieve fast growth. Because of this consumers now have an expectation for free.

Previously when software was sold at retail, consumers had no qualms paying for software.

So maybe you are right and the root problem are the business models and specifically the funding behind those models.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by vageli on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:04PM (#20192134)
> The reason why consumers are unwilling to pay for service is because VCs have funded companies ability to give away tremendous value to achieve fast growth. Because of this consumers now have an expectation for free.

> Previously when software was sold at retail, consumers had no qualms paying for software.

When was this? I recall the warez, cracking and keygen scenes being huge years ago (before the rise of SaaS).

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by anonymousab on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:34PM (#20192300)
In this case 'people' does not mean 'every single person' but rather 'a significantly large enough amount of people as to represent a valid business model in many cases'.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by meesles on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:26PM (#20192272)
That misses the point. Theft and hacking are still prevalent, that hasn't changed. What's changed is that people expect software like Facebook, Twitter, or Gmail for free. Decades ago the average consumer walked into a Fry's or Microcenter and bought their copy of Windows.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by dageshi on Saturday June 15, 2019 @06:16PM (#20192525)
No.. the early internet was pretty much all free to read, the only thing that's ever really been able to charge is porn. For everything else if it looks like a website, acts like a website then people expect it to be free. Try to charge and people will move on.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by enitihas on Saturday June 15, 2019 @04:51PM (#20192071)
How would we as a society decide that? The majority of society is more concerned with putting food on the table and paying their rent, and would have zero interest in deciding to get rid of "paid by data" products. Unless we as a society can provide everyone the basic amenities first(food,home,maybe a job), I am not sure people are willing to let go these seemingly free services. Getting control of your data is very important, but the vast majority of humans have many far more pressing concerns.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by deogeo on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:10PM (#20192164)
"Do nothing until we've solved poverty."

And there are many assumptions in your post that are not necessarily true:

1. Services could still be free to most users, with paid versions that provide more functionality.

2. Privacy invasion and advertising has a cost, that those very people worrying about food have to pay. They don't have to pay 2$/month for e-mail, but then will spend N$ for the expertly marketed toy/cereal their child is throwing a tantrum over, and their own purchasing choices will also be affected adversely - advertising works.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by kekebo on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:06PM (#20192144)
The assumption that most of western society is busy with securing basic survival seems like a constructed knockout argument. The fact that you are here to discuss the matter indicates that doesn't apply to yourself for instance.

As for how society would decide it, I see consumer pressure as decisive, the more ethical handling of data becomes a selling point, the more financial incentives companies have to implement and market it. It's visible right now in how Apple positions itself against Google as the more privacy minded company with enough public appraisal to challenge, if not invalidate, your assumption.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by black_bird on Saturday June 15, 2019 @06:48PM (#20192669)
There is no "we" in this. I would express it: >Why should "I" accept that privacy intrusions are okay?

As long as it's a voluntary business relationship, there's nothing to say. If your scale of preferences tells you that privacy is a more important factor than the service itself, then use the services that suit your demand, but don't prevent others from acting differently.

>If we as a society decide to limit how companies can collect and use our data...

Why? I don't have the right to decide for you. If you decide to get married, do I have the right to tell you how to proceed in your contractual relationship with your partner? As long as it is a voluntary contract and the individual rights of others are respected..., does the rest of society or the government have the right to decide or impose rules for you or your partner on how your association proceeds?

"Take it, leave it or shut up." If the concept of "privacy" is as important to society as it is to you, it will lead to an increase in demand and supply linked to services that incorporate greater privacy into their products. You don't need to do anything about it, but whatever you try to do in an arbitrary, subjective and coercive way, it will be objectively immoral and violent towards the rest of the people.

>Companies don't have a right to their business model. They have that right because we all have it, just as you have the right to plan your life but you don't have the right to plan someone else's life.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by jakelazaroff on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:40PM (#20193715)
Should you be able to sell human organs? Child pornography? If you agree to let someone pay your family and kill you, should they be chargeable with murder?

These are all voluntary business relationships. They're illegal because society has mostly agreed that there should be a limit to how much a transaction can extract from someone. That people, even at their most desperate, should still be protected.

And yes, the bounds here can be arbitrary. Selling organs is illegal while selling sperm and eggs is not. But ultimately, most everyone agrees that we should draw the line somewhere. The entire point of a society is a set of norms around how to interact with others.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by majewsky on Saturday June 15, 2019 @07:32PM (#20192858)
> If your scale of preferences tells you that privacy is a more important factor than the service itself, then use the services that suit your demand, but don't prevent others from acting differently.

That's completely ignoring network effects: I want to delete WhatsApp from my phone. But if I do so, it means I won't be taking part in everyday family life anymore.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by black_bird on Saturday June 15, 2019 @08:11PM (#20193002)
Then you agree with me. Your preference is greater for "being in contact with someone" than your privacy or other factors. Case closed. Or are you saying that someone should force your family members to use another product that suits your personal preferences?
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by majewsky on Sunday June 16, 2019 @12:38PM (#20196370)
I'm saying that, as a society, we should not allow products that don't respect people's fundamental freedoms. The disagreement between us is whether privacy should be considered a constitution-level fundamental freedom. In fact, in my country (Germany), the Supreme Court has ruled that it is.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by el_programmador on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:46PM (#20192368)
What if the plebeians don't mind privacy intrusions? What if they are happy to give away their privacy on a platter if they are getting free email, digital maps, traffic stats, cloud drive and a whole lot of other goodies from Google? Never underestimate the power of freebies!
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by inetknght on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:59PM (#20192437)
Plebeians? Is that what you think of people who are too busy, working to pay for basic food and living conditions, to take any time whatsoever to understand how they still pay even for "freebies"?
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by el_programmador on Sunday June 16, 2019 @01:17AM (#20193963)
Plebeians here means common people or the commoners, no need to get triggered!
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by inetknght on Sunday June 16, 2019 @01:20AM (#20193971)
Do you not consider yourself "common people"? I consider myself common.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by el_programmador on Sunday June 16, 2019 @05:52AM (#20194738)
Yep exactly. I consider myself common that's why I don't get offended by the word "plebeian". In my books, plebeian is just a synonym for "commoners", there is no other meaning to it.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by esoterica on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:10PM (#20192162)
Why are you so sure that that's what "society" wants? Most people do not want to pay Google $20/month to look stuff up on the Internet. If that's what you think "society" wants then you live in a hermetic bubble.
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by black_bird on Saturday June 15, 2019 @07:05PM (#20192738)
I'm with you. Again and again we see how certain conclusions and opinions expressed on this site presuppose a global knowledge about the preferences of other people. Regulators, planners and collectivists assume that what is bad for them must be bad for others, that what is good for them must be good for everyone and therefore "have" the right to force people to act as they think they should act according to their arbitrary criteria.

If "society" requires services with a greater emphasis on privacy, they will be more in demand and will find their corresponding offer in the marketplace.

>Why we can't have privacy on the internet... Bullshit. We can have whatever we want, but if I demand something I must offer something in return, be it money, private data or unicorns. There is no such thing as a free coffee.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by FridgeSeal on Saturday June 15, 2019 @08:15PM (#20193019)
> they will be more in demand and will find their corresponding offer in the marketplace.

Ah yes, the classic refrain of “the free market will just fix everything” despite that, you know, not being the case time-and-time-again.

A huge number of products and services these days are “supply driven demand”, so consumers voting with your wallet is extremely limited in scope and power: you’re not being given a representative set of available options, you’re being given the choice between a few-often superficially different- options that companies are happy to provide. Coupled with the fact that many companies and the advertising industry as a whole has pushed a narrative of “just give up all your data, it’s fiiiinnne” means consumers aren’t informed or aware of all the options they could demand. Add in the fact that a huge number of people simply don’t have the luxury of shopping around for their preferred product at every opportunity.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by black_bird on Saturday June 15, 2019 @09:13PM (#20193226)
> "the free market will just fix everything" I think the market doesn't fix anything because there's nothing to fix in this case.

> you're not being given a representative set of available options...

What would those options be? Who decides that? For me the market does, who should do it for you? What I'm saying is simple, if there are more people who demand services that respect their privacy, then the offer of those services will arise. If, for example, we are in an abstemious society no one will demand wine, then it is foolish to try to produce wine under those circumstances. It will only be profitable to produce wine there if the preferences of that society change.

>"just give up all your data, it's fiiiinnne" I don't know. It may or may not be fine, you decide for you and I decide for me. I'm not going to force you to make a decision you don't want and I hope you do the same.

Anyway, it's silly to say that we can't have privacy on the Internet. My position is that we can have the services we want, privacy, security, with whatever preponderant factor we want to have, but not for free. You will pay with money, with personal data or whatever the other party accepts as payment, but you will always pay. All this discussion takes place only in contexts where there are people who think they can access all kinds of things for "free", who have the right to dispose of someone else's work, capital, time or property as they please.

Whether we like it or not, the market currently tells us that, in general, access to certain services is more valuable than consumer privacy.

Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by johnchristopher on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:16AM (#20195541)
Still relevant today and for historical perspective: https://www.wired.com/2008/02/ff-free/ (Free is the new price)
Re:Why we can't have privacy on the internet (2018) by agumonkey on Sunday June 16, 2019 @01:03AM (#20193937)
being ok was not the point, society moves before laws are made, and to pay their bills they found selling user logs were a way to do so

they probably discussed making people pay a small fee but I'm sure many web things died when they asked for money