I like Colin and all, but have never met him. We tend to talk to each other a lot because we have very similar interests. You're as likely to see us bickering with each other as not.
I don't really know Jacques at all.
Any time you're in Chicago, look me up; I'm happy to buy coffee (we're on top of an excellent coffee shop downtown). I met a different HN person every other month or so just doing that.
I prefer to call it debating. :-)
Also, to your parent, pretty much everyone I've ever emailed from HN has been friendly, and the ones I've met in real life have been great, too. Familiarity is the way that community is built. I've emailed all of those HNers except Colin before, when appropriate, and I still randomly know cpercival's name.
But as other people have said, it all comes out of seeing each other's comments here. There is no secret cabal, unless you count the YC founders mailing list (which I'm not part of).
I know I'm connected with tptacek by one degree and linkedin tells me I'm connected to patrick within two degrees through two different people.
Someone should write a six degrees of HN app :-)
tptacek and patio11 probably met here, both have Chicago connections, met in person and now have done business together.
tptacek and cperciva are both in the security/crypto world. Don't know where they met but get the impression that they would have some connections regardless of HN.
Not sure about any connections outside of HN with jacquesm.
The way I see it, the HN "elite" spend a fair amount of time here, build relationships based on similar interests here on HN (maybe eventually in real life) and then appear to everyone else as if they've always know each other.
I have the karma of a simple country boy. As a HN reader, I read many of tptacek's comments, and in particular his invitation in his profile to "Don't apologize for contacting me! I'm happy to meet you." So I ran into him at HN Chicago, we talked, one thing led to another, and now I work at Matasano.
So you know about the club by reaching out to anyone you find interesting.
I am not a member of any other group that is as friendly and accessible as this one here.
If it's the latter, is 4k karma enough to join? ;)