Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st...
by dwild on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @11:29AM
(#20214162)
How can you both say...
> Rather, my argument was that for a legal service to displace piracy, it would need to be closer to its advantages.
and
> I was not concerned with the feasibility of such a service.
in the same paragraph?
I'm arguing that it's not feasible. I'm arguing that you can't compete, thus "if a good enough service would exist" return "false" all the time. That's it.
> Right now, it’s getting farther away.
It's not getting farther, it's at the same place, you are just paying the true cost of the service.
Which is an extension of your first paragraph, which is not what I was replying to, hence why it wasn’t the section I quoted.
Your argument further down was that you no longer believe (“I believed that argument for far too long”) that “illegal content would happen less if a good enough service would exist”. Well, a “good enough” service doesn’t exist. My suggestion was that for some of these pirates, a “good enough” legal service would need to allow them the same advantages they have with piracy, and cost the same as what they pay now for a VPN / seedbox.
I was not concerned with the feasibility of such a service. Rather, my argument was that for a legal service to displace piracy, it would need to be closer to its advantages. Right now, it’s getting farther away.