News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by oh_sigh on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @04:28PM (#20168955)
Ok, so you're walking down the street with a locked phone in your pocket. I send an Android Bluetooth 0-day payload to your phone. Nothing wrong with that, after all I'm just asking your phone if it wants to copy some bytes, and it says 'sure!'. Not my problem if your phone does something funky with those bytes.

Now I have root, and copy off all of your pictures and private data onto my device. Nothing wrong with that, just copying some bytes, right?

Finally, I have all of your data, no contractual obligations to you on how I use it. So I'll just copy some bytes over to Twitter or Instagram and publish your private photos to the world. That's all ok in your book, because all the time I'm just copying bytes?

Your point is so reductivist that it is absurd. It's like declaring that any human action is just wiggling of fingers or flapping of vocal chords, and what can be so bad with wiggling fingers or flapping vocal cords?

Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by jMyles on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @04:37PM (#20169029)
You've glossed over the important part.

Yes, in a free society, it's my responsibility to be a ward against 0-days. This is the problem with unduly complex and / or closed source software and closed, proprietary hardware being in our pockets in the first place.

To paint over these problems by restraining basic, fundamental speech (ie, you can repeat anything you know to anyone, specific contracts notwithstanding) is throwing away the baby instead of the bathwater.

[dead]
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by jMyles on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @04:51PM (#20169185)
As a matter of maintaining mental health, I stop responding when threads devolve into "think of the children!"

I hope you can understand.

Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by oh_sigh on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @07:05PM (#20170265)
I'm not saying think of the children. I'm not even making an arugment with that previous post - I'm probing your viewpoints to see if your worldview truly allows free sharing of information from one party to another as it appears you claimed.

I could have just as easily said terrorist propaganda, beheading videos, revenge porn, bomb making manuals, or a lot of other things. My point is to find out if you really believe in unrestrained speech, or if you yourself have limits to what is allowable free speech vs unallowable.

Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by kelnos on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @07:21PM (#20170363)
The crime here, in my mind, wasn't posting bytes on a website, but was breaking into someone's phone. Which is already illegal.
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by oh_sigh on Wednesday June 12, 2019 @07:47PM (#20170517)
Okay, so I commit a crime and steal all sorts of personal data from a phone, but then hand that data off to someone else - who knows that I did something naughty to obtain it - who then posts it for all the world to see.

That second person did nothing wrong?

Also, did I really break into the phone? I just hypothetically asked if it wanted to copy some bytes, and it said yes.

Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by awaythrow113 on Thursday June 13, 2019 @04:32AM (#20172789)
A phone can't say anything, it doesn't have agency. What you did was exploit around security measures, which is breaking into the phone.
Re:Shazam-like technology used to identify bars illegally st... by oh_sigh on Thursday June 13, 2019 @01:53PM (#20177147)
Yes - so just reducing anything a computer does to 'copying bytes' is a ridiculous thing. Which was my entire point.