News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by rolltiide on Saturday June 08, 2019 @03:35PM (#20134599)
I wonder how long before Merriam-Webster and Oxford include porn definitions as the conflicting sexual and non-sexual connotations

Google already does, anything that arouses senses.

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by NikkiA on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:14PM (#20134867)
dictionary.com (I always thought they ran on M-W's wordlists?) is ahead of you:

PORN - Sometimes por·no [pawr-noh] /ˈpɔr noʊ/. pornography;

1 sexually explicit videos, photographs, writings, or the like, produced to elicit sexual arousal (often used attributively): arrested for selling porn; a porn star; porn films.

2 television shows, articles, photographs, etc., thought to cater to an excessive, irresistible desire for or interest in something:

edit: This seems to be based on the Cambridge dictionary (which is generally more commonly used in the UK outside of higher-level academia and journalism than the OED)

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by Fnoord on Saturday June 08, 2019 @03:46PM (#20134667)
First sentence from Wikipedia article [1]

> Pornography (often abbreviated porn) is the portrayal of sexual subject matter for the exclusive purpose of sexual arousal.

The slang version just means 'pictures I appreciate'.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by rolltiide on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:08PM (#20134820)
It's not clear why you wrote this

You just took the worst source for an English definition, felt compelled to actually include the source as if to dispel unproductive skeptical responses, and then explained what the slang version was in response to a comment telling you both the actual and slang definitions, who had asked when the slang definition will be upgraded for inclusion in the best sources for English definitions

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by Fnoord on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:16PM (#20134875)
> You just took the worst source for an English definition

I'll agree to disagree with you on that one.

As for my point. My point is that the word porn/porno/pornography doesn't mean what you said it does for Wikipedia. Which suggests for a large population of the world (including myself). That it has that meaning on Reddit or amongst youth is just cargo culture.

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by rolltiide on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:43PM (#20135037)
It looks like Oxford and others already have included the expanded definition.

You would be in the minority by elevating Wikipedia over them, and I can just as easily modify Wikipedia and also give sources to their curators to gain consensus there. Will your opinion magically change because of that?

You don't have to use the word that way, you just have to know what people are referring to and viola language is achieved. Cargo culture is also part of the living dictionary, Oxford has accepted that before you.

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by Fnoord on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:49PM (#20135073)
> You would be in the minority by elevating Wikipedia over them, and I can just as easily modify Wikipedia and also give sources to their curators to gain consensus there. Will your opinion magically change because of that?

Go for it, and yeah it would (tho it isn't a binary yes/no). I would still know that, generally, the new definition is popularly used among the younger people of our society; not the adolescents and elder. The question with definitions like these is whether they're keepers ie. whether they remain in use on the longer term.

> Cargo culture is also part of the living dictionary

Cargo cult isn't a definition with such seemingly conflicting meanings.

> Oxford has accepted that before you.

Irrelevant, and you don't know that for sure either.

Re:I made a SFW porn viewer from Reddit subs by rolltiide on Sunday June 09, 2019 @12:34PM (#20140171)
I'm not a fan of this use of the word porn, I think it is awkward and can make some benign interesting topics seem unsafe for work, which is the only reason I wrote my original comment.

But it is interesting how that revealed your antiquated thoughts on consensus and how that relates to the utility and cataloguing of language and how that relates that to mere communication itself. What we have is an easy to understand term, moving from slang to non-slang by various sources just from continual use. It doesn't make it difficult for you to understand, and you also don't have to use it and only understand. So it is interesting how you expand that to an inconsequential pedestal.

I would be curious if it remains in use on the longer term. I hope not. But the inclusion in these other dictionaries - whether someone modifies wikipedia or not - just makes it last longer.