And eye witness testimony is often terrible. It's disappointing that circumstantial evidence gets such a bad rap.
Very unlikely things happen all the time. But beyond a certain level of unlikeliness, combined with a strong motive, it has to be enough.
And of course in practice everyone gets this because cases are decided every day by this implicit understanding.
Some circumstantial evidence is very strong, as when you
find a trout in the milk.
-- Henry David ThoreauYou can say that about most evidence. Even the classic "smoking gun" metaphor is an example of circumstantial evidence.
It's just a way for people to dismiss a claim without actually having to argue against a claim. If the evidence is tenuous or weak, explain why.
For instance, the fact that Solotshi is similar to Satoshi. That's just dumb. If you're going to pick a pseudonym to hide your identity for the long term, you don't pick one that's just a variation of your name.
However, if every other piece of evidence was much better, then dude just picked a bad pseudonym.
And we also have to consider that a lot of weak signals can become a strong signal. Like the name thing is what I'd call an extremely weak signal. But if there's an overwhelming flood of such weak signals, then it starts looking much more likely.
Circumstantial evidence is often strong enough and compelling enough to determine court cases. Circumstantial evidence is often better than direct evidence.
Circumstantial evidence: Stuff like DNA, fingerprints
Direct evidence: Bob's memory of the event.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circumstantial_evidence
But please, continue using "the evidence is circumstantial" as if it means that it's not good enough.