Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Why aren’t more companies remote-first?. Parent comment
1) Private office - I've had this, it was great
2) Shared office - had this too, it's ok if you have a good officemate
3) Team room - had this, larger office/conference room for one team, you have to be able to close the door
4) private cubicle, high walls - had this, pairing was easy
5) private cubicle, low walls - had this, a few more egregious interruptions
6) shared cubicle - haven't had this, still beats open office
7) open plan, big desks - at this now, it still lacks privacy and noise control
8) open plan, benching - had this, 36" of bench space, had to carry my laptop, mouse and office supplies with me
9) open plan, hot desking - IMO, this is just cause for a resignation letter on ergonomic and dehumanization grounds.
TL; DR: Cubicles are better for concentration and privacy than open plan, not as good as offices. Open plan makes me nostalgic for cubicles.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
1) Private office - I've had this, it was great
2) Shared office - had this too, it's ok if you have a good officemate
3) Team room - had this, larger office/conference room for one team, you have to be able to close the door
4) private cubicle, high walls - had this, pairing was easy
5) private cubicle, low walls - had this, a few more egregious interruptions
6) shared cubicle - haven't had this, still beats open office
7) open plan, big desks - at this now, it still lacks privacy and noise control
8) open plan, benching - had this, 36" of bench space, had to carry my laptop, mouse and office supplies with me
9) open plan, hot desking - IMO, this is just cause for a resignation letter on ergonomic and dehumanization grounds.
TL; DR: Cubicles are better for concentration and privacy than open plan, not as good as offices. Open plan makes me nostalgic for cubicles.