Re:Quantum Leaps, Long Assumed to Be Instantaneous, Take Time
by trurl42 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:48PM
(#20108968)
That would be 2.
What's done in such an experiment is that we initialize a quantum state in a particular state (that this is possible is not actually obvious, but let's assume it's true) and then we make a lot of repeated measurements after different amounts of times.
So we're not talking about a single system, but instead about statistics about a set of measurements with systems that have been set up in the same initial state. (Each system only being measured once after a certain time after it's being set up).
Re:Quantum Leaps, Long Assumed to Be Instantaneous, Take Time
by neaanopri on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:58PM
(#20109059)
Gotcha, so the ideas of "Shut Up and Calculate" QM about wavefunction collapse for ideal systems aren't incomplete.
Re:Quantum Leaps, Long Assumed to Be Instantaneous, Take Time
by gaze on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:50PM
(#20108991)
The system is being measured, collapses DO take time, but this is not news to people who study certain branches of quantum information. The experiment confirming it though is a breakthrough.
My understanding of QM is that a quantum's system's state is suddenly and discontinuously changed by a measurement.
My understanding of this article is a bit confused, and I think that there are two possible things we could be seeing: 1. Quantum collapses of superpositions actually do take time ("This Changes Everything") 2. This particular quantum system is not actually being measured, but is oscillating in superposition in some odd way. ("Just a Particular System")
Which case is it?