News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:49AM (#20103056)
Good. The world was okay before there was an oil industry and it will be better off when it no longer has one.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by Angostura on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:55AM (#20103085)
For certain values of 'okay'. There is no doubt that oil and plastics have been hugely beneficial in many respects. The problem is that the cost is now apparent and we must stop gorging on them. Reduction in plastic and oil can only be a good thing but let's not pretend it doesn't require substantial changes in the way that we all live - its not just disposable straws here.

Reading the article, the projection is that this could "cut petrochemical demand growth to one-third of its historical pace, to about 1.5% a year".

That's good enough. I don't want to see reduced growth rate. I want to see shrinkage.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by lucideer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:11AM (#20103160)
> let's not pretend it doesn't require substantial changes in the way that we all live

Actually, I don't really believe this. I do use/consume a lot of plastic, but I find in practice that in the vast majority of cases, the decision to make those items from plastic is an arbitrary one. The market has made decidision on my behalf, and provided me with a range of plastic options, with very few non-plastic options, for an application that has no hard dependency on plastic.

Electronics would be one of the big ones, and can largely be (and often are) made with aluminium* casings. Fittings have similar metallic alternatives. PCBs are something of an exception here: yes, there are aluminium/metallic substrates, but even those are epoxy-insulated.

Most other plastic uses are similar stories: we're provided with a range of exclusively plastic choices by the market, but that doesn't make it necessary on the production end.

Plastic is usually cheaper, yes, but this is a result of a long chain of subsidies, wars, and other market interference. This doesn't reflect true production cost.

* Worth noting, the environmental impact story for aluminium/other metals isn't too great either, but that's a separate topic.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by challenger22 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:57AM (#20103460)
The true cost of plastic is cheaper by far than aluminum or other alternatives. Injection molding and other plastic technologies are miraculously productive and energy efficient compared to many other forms of production.

The U.S. produces 12,000,000 barrels of oil per day. 4,380,000 barrels per year. According to https://cleantechnica.com/2017/10/14/u-s-tax-code-4-6-billio..., we also subsidise this production by $4B per year, or about a dollar a barrel.

If you are saying that a $1 per barrel subsidy for oil causes the cost of plastic widgets to shrink appreciably, I think you are very wrong.

If you are saying that the total cost of the Iraq war should be rolled into the cost of plastic widgets, I think you are very wrong.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by lucideer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:07AM (#20103522)
> If you are saying that the total cost of the Iraq war should be rolled into the cost of plastic widgets, I think you are very wrong.

I am saying that. I'm also saying the cost of the lifecycle of plastic production and recycling/disposal, including environmental cost (which we have plenty of proxies for these days in terms of representing using economic metrics) should be rolled in.

(and yes, the same goes for aluminium: it too has ancillary costs to consider)

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by Scaevolus on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:21AM (#20103232)
You don't need subsidies for injection molded plastics to be massively cheaper to produce than any comparable material. Machining aluminum is very expensive, and die casting metal requires much more expensive tooling than plastics.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:25AM (#20103264)
Also the choice to use petrochemical plastic rather than plant derived plastic or some equivalent non-plastic is mostly "because it's there". The industry exists, so its products are cheaper in the supply chain, so by the time you get to consumer level all the decisions have been made and it's the only choice offered.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by saiya-jin on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:52AM (#20103421)
Well the world is bigger than your view, needs or experience. There are many industrial appliances where plastics is not only cheapest, but also the overall best solution. Same would go for example for medicine.

Can it be fully replaced? Yes, but it will really take quite a bit of effort, or even going back to already phased out tools and materials.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by lucideer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:12AM (#20103557)
I think you may have misinterpreted my post: I think we agree.

It would take an almost impossible effort (I'm not optimistic) on the part of industry. The only point I was rebutting is that our day-to-day consumer needs could not be met without plastic without significant lifestyle change by private individuals. I don't believe that this is true.

But yes, the change required on an holistic level is pretty much insurmountable.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by Dumblydorr on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:58AM (#20103870)
Plastic is revolutionary in the medical field, that may be one of the final niches where its use cannot be prevented.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by lucideer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:19AM (#20105291)
This is fine. There are niche uses for every material. The idea is for it not to be the default for every possible application.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by cardamomo on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:09AM (#20103152)
> That's good enough. I don't want to see reduced growth rate. I want to see shrinkage.

Perhaps you mean that's not good enough?

I, too, want to see the oil industry shrink. To my mind, it's downright dangerous to devote such a large part of the global economy to an industry that is literally putting our planet in peril.

The larger conversation we need to have, however, is what a post- growth economy should look like.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by Angostura on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:00AM (#20103892)
I did mean not thank you :) I also agree about the conversation about post-growth
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by kace91 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:59AM (#20103106)
I think OP's comment was a commentary about the oil industry, rather than oil and derivate products themselves.

As in, there might be a lot of downsides to reducing or getting rid of plastic use, but the fall of oil giants is not one of them.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by MasterPI on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:12AM (#20103168)
I doubt the world would have been able to enjoy such a technological progress in general without oil to even have computers and be able to post comments on here for example.

Not denying that the oil industry hasn't got any sins.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by growlist on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:11AM (#20103158)
Extremely unlikely any of us alive now will be alive to see it. Oil is just far too useful for us to be able to replace easily, and choosing not to replace it would take our lifestyles back hundreds of years. Hardly anyone wants that.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:34AM (#20103311)
Up until the sixties or seventies asbestos was just far too useful to be replaced easily.

It was used everywhere - as filler, as insulation, as fire retardant, and was so cheap it even got used as bulking agent, as fake snow for Xmas and in packaging. We got rid of it in new applications in just a few years once it was realised that the health cost was far in excess of its utility. It costs thousands to rip out some of the old insulation in buildings, especially where it's part of the fabric of the building.

Lead in petrol was far to useful to be replaced, etc etc...

I just think it's part of the new innovation debt coming due. It's only now coming due for plastics and oil and the extreme cost of profligate unconstrained use is starting to be realised.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:53AM (#20103426)
It's basically a hubristic mistake to take "this substance is useful!" as sufficient justification to introduce it as a novelty in huge amounts without considering its whole lifetime flow through the world's cycles, physical and biological.

It comes from thinking of the planet as infinite and able to absorb anything thrown into it, rather than a closed cycle life support system.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by growlist on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:14AM (#20103986)
I'm not justifying anything and probably agree with you and NeedMoreTea in general. That said, asbestos and lead are barely comparable. Virtually every aspect of modern life is currently dependent on oil. You live in houses built with oil, wash yourself in water cleaned and transported in no small part with oil, drive on roads built with oil, wear clothes created with oil in one way or another, and eat food grown with oil. To think that we can unwind the phenomenally deep and complex interweaving of oil into the global economy in short order without massive disruption is not realistic.

I'm no fan of oil either, but let's not get carried away.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:11PM (#20107416)
The 1900s were deeply enmeshed with horses. The 1900s - 1950s with coal.

A house need not depend on oil - bricks can still be fired and glass made from carbon neutral electricity, pipes can be copper, and drainage use ceramic like was used until the 80s. Similar for transport, water treatment etc. Perhaps a few specialised uses of PVC and other plastics will remain and the rest go - regulated or priced from existence. Now 95% of coal and horses aren't around we still keep stables for fun, some still enjoy horse racing, steam trains run at weekends and museums run a few steam engines.

Thing is the assumption that the planet could take everything thrown at it used to work - now population has grown so much that no longer applies. JulianMorrison has a point that "it's useful" can no longer be enough - stuff isn't only used by a few wealthy types any more, on a planet with under 1bn, whilst most of those engage in agriculture. We have to learn to consider damage control and restriction far sooner than was necessary even in the 1930s.

My worry is the modern dogma to not want to impact business at all costs. Governments avoid strong regulation, requiring consideration of the land a business occupy, the pollution and waste they cause or the people whose needs they should serve. Essentially they became subservient to multinationals. It will make changing that much harder and fought against much more - not least by those oil interests.

Not easy, but not impossible either. There is precedent after all. :)

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by growlist on Monday June 10, 2019 @04:44AM (#20144945)
Again - I don't disagree we need to change, but I think we need to be honest about the scale of the disruption involved. Think about the amount of debt in the world, and imagine that that was created with the foundation of an oil based economy, and then imagine what would happen if that foundation were removed. We are talking potentially catastrophic economic crisis, with all the problems that would bring.

The final thing I would say is that if those in control are sincere about tackling climate change, an open borders immigration policy is a very strange thing for them to be promoting. Instead of supporting people to live good lives where they are - in low carbon countries - we are encouraging them to move to high carbon countries, and effectively creating a reason to generate massive amounts of carbon through house building, infrastructure etc. This is one of the main reasons I am sceptical about the messages that come down from on high, and even more so given that the stock response to this issue is accusations of racism etc.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by sliken on Friday June 07, 2019 @01:52AM (#20121973)
Seems crazy pessimistic. We could use HUGELY less plastic without a major impact. Start with clothes, get rid of all nylon, polyester, and plastic based materials. World changing? Hardly.

Get rid of plastic forks, spoons, knives, and straws... again no big deal.

Get rid of plastic used in food. Milk jugs, processed food, tv dinners, plastic bags of lemons/potatoes/etc. Kill off water bottles (which are a waste anyways), soda packages in plastic, cheap boxed wine, etc.

Sure there's some harder things, like say fertilizer, car interiors, toys, keyboards, mice, watches, network cables, etc. But still we could hugely reduce are use of oil.

Sadly the world was just starting to move away from oil a bit, then USA went from a large oil importer, to a huge exporter and the prices dropped.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by sureaboutthis on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:23AM (#20103243)
Oil may be the easiest solution to the original problem. If there were no oil, would there have been a different solution that might have been as easy?
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by S_A_P on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:42AM (#20103358)
This comment means that you don't completely understand the full scope of what the oil industry does. I say that as someone who wants to see less dependence on the oil industry.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by Dumblydorr on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:04PM (#20106548)
It's alright, we can have dozens of uses still and simultaneously tackle ICE engines first while other solutions scale up.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by cafebabbe on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:36AM (#20103326)
Without fossil fuels, no Haber-Bosch process. No Haber-Bosch process, no fertilizers. No fertilizers, no food security.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by mimac on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:49AM (#20103408)
The Haber-Bosch process is not dependent on fossil fuels. With renewable sources (biogas instead of methane for H2 generation) the process is more expensive, but there are no technical limitations here that mandate the use of fossil fuels.

With advances in biotech and possible harnessing of biological nitrogen fixation we might overcome even this...

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:38AM (#20103336)
And that's just one of the many ways that hydrocarbons are woven into critical parts of the global economy.

You can't just snap your fingers, make oil go away and expect modern civilization to keep existing as it currently does.

It took ~150yr to get the oil industry where it is today and that is with a massive financial incentive. People need lubricants, tars, fuels, plastics, everything that oil makes cheaply and well. In the absence of strong organic (not artificial, i.e. regulatory compliance) incentives to stop using oil it will almost certainly take much longer than 150yr to reduce oil usage for energy/fuel to negligible levels. We will likely never stop using oil for plastics, fertilizers and other "critical to modern civilization" things until something that's cheaper and equivalent or better comes along for every last use case.

Keep in mind that whatever we have next will have tradeoffs too.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by dTal on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:10AM (#20103537)
Oil-the-chemical and oil-the-fuel can be considered seperate products. Demand-wise, all uses besides fuel are trivial. Even plastic is only 4%. The spritz of 10W-40 on my bike chain is of 0 consequence compared to the gallon of gas burned in a typical daily commute by car. We're never going to run out of oil for all those important non-fuel uses. Even if every oil well ran dry tomorrow, oil-the-chemical is quite easy to make from carbon waste feedstock.

I don't think it's right to estimate such a long time for oil to become obsolete as a fuel, just because we use it for other things too.

Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by growlist on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:16AM (#20103995)
Couldn't put it better.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:46AM (#20103384)
Without artificial fertilizers, soil depletion can stop and we can start using various permaculture farming techniques instead that can be sustained long term.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by FooBarWidget on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:49AM (#20103403)
Wait, what? What's wrong with composting manure and kitchen scrap?
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:55AM (#20103438)
Contamination in both cases, unfortunately.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by FooBarWidget on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:01AM (#20103481)
What sort of contamination?
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by JulianMorrison on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:10PM (#20109662)
Household and commercial cleaning chemicals, agricultural hormones, antibiotics, cleaning chemicals, stuff like that.
Re:The Backlash to Plastic Has Oil Companies Worried by ibz on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:45AM (#20103376)
Ironically, it's actually chemical fertilizers that destroy our food security long term.