(1) You have to know what Twitter's financials look like. You can speculate, but since they're not public, you don't know. It may be the case that based on the financials, the growth, and a few simple spreadsheets, KPCB figured out a valuation that makes them comfortable buying at $3.7b.
(2) You have to know what the investor's goal is. Different VCs have different funds with different models. Funds that invest in late stage companies don't expect to make huge returns. They might see a path to a risk-free exit at $5 billion in two years. Investing at $3.7b for an exit in two years at $5b is a great investment for certain types of investors. Other types of investors are investing earlier stage and need 10x or 20x returns to make up for the complete failures in their portfolio.
(3) When talking about large companies with user bases the size of Twitter or Facebook, the very size of the user base can make the common stock much more valuable in a public offering. Think about how many dentists and lawyers are going to invest in Facebook on the day of its IPO because "everybody they know uses Facebook." Meanwhile, another, much more profitable B2B company that only has 1000 customers can be completely invisible to the public at large so the demand for their stock in an IPO would be weaker.
(4) $10b exits may be rare, but Twitter is a rare company. You don't see a lot of companies getting 8% of online Americans in a year or two.
(5) There is a very short list of investors with the midas touch. The very fact that they are investing in something makes it more valuable. John Doerr is certainly in this category. He can invest in Brown Paper Bags and make money simply because so many other investors trust him and will buy anything he buys.
(6) It might not be a sensible deal. The people investing in it might be idiots.
I'm sure they aren't either, but every bubble in history wasn't caused by people being sensible.
Both Facebook and Twitter are in serious bubble positions, just like MySpace and Friendster and pets.com.
The odds are very high that the money will go the same place Murdoch's billions went - down the closest toilet. Let's keep in mind that people thought Rupert got a sweet hart - even criminal - deal with MySpace at the time. In hindsight he looks like an idiot.
When the company in question has no reasonably identifiable income stream and stratospheric valuations, it's best to stay far, far away.
Murdoch did get an amazing deal.
Revenues are meaningless. MySpace last reported a profit in 2007, of $10 mil on $550 mil in revenue.
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/fox-interactive-turns-annual-p...
Facebook then proceeded to eat MySpace's lunch.
August 2010 article about how News Corp. may never profit from MySpace:
http://www.bnet.com/blog/advertising-business/news-corp-may-...
MySpace's current market value is nowhere close to the $5 billion you claim. It has been hemorrhaging market share to Facebook for years.
Just check out the graphs.
http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/myspace.com
Steady drop toward zero.
No-one's disputing that Facebook are beating MySpace, but saying they're worthless is like saying Pepsi are worthless because they're not Coke.
At the revenue levels they're at and at the size of their employee base, they could easily cut costs and make back that 327 million in a single year (at the cost of long term growth). Regardless if you think they're worth 1 billion or 5 billion, they're clearly worth more than worth Murdoch paid for it.
He could sell tomorrow for the price he paid for it and have private equity buyers bite his hand off.
In order for something to be worth anything at all, it needs a buyer willing to agree to that number.
I'm not sure MySpace has such an optimist.
With liquidation preferences, it's possible that even an immediate sale to an acquirer for $3.9B might give these latest investors some guaranteed return.
I don't know what the odds are, but surely there's at least a 25% chance that twitter will fizzle out. So it's 25% chance of nothing, and 75% chance of, say, a 3x exit. I dunno, that seems crazy risky to me.
Someone commented below about the secondary market - that actually makes a lot of sense I think. I guess when you're investing in twitter there's enough liquidity in the secondary market that you can probably get out if you need to.
If these are the odds, the expected outcome would be that you more then double your money. 25%0+75%3=2.25
So 25% chance of nothing is almost certainly wrong.
Twitter can just as easily be great for it's stakeholders and fizzle out as a service.
Do you think ICQ is worth $10B?
Facebook is hugely profitable, but its messages are private...
And calling Facebook "hugely profitable" is a stretch.
Since "making something people want" is generally considered a harder problem than monetizing that service when you have something people want, it's not entirely irrational to focus on the former before the latter, even if it doesn't always pan out.
At a $3.7 billion valuation doesn't that mean that twitter has to IPO or be bought for at least $10 billion to make it worth it? and aren't those exits exceedingly rare?
I'm sure people investing $200million aren't idiots, so it's not like this logic is lost on them, so I'd be really interested in what the investment terms are to make this a sensible deal.