News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaving .Net by bad_user on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @04:46AM (#2007588)

      GCC which has probably 10x more people working on it than 
      any commercial compiler
Citation?

Personally I think you pulled that figure out of your ass; especially since the GCC codebase is a mess (on purpose), it's been stable and good enough (and arguably stagnant) for quite a while and all attention shifts lately to LLVM.

     With relatively small developer teams, they've increased in 
     quality as fast as any open source projects I know of
When speaking of both Silverlight / ASP.NET MVC ... they are copying other projects. And we aren't talking only about high-level ideas here, but actual implementation details.

They are great followers, yes, but what did you expect from a company with virtually unlimited cash?

Re:Leaving .Net by kenjackson on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @01:28PM (#2009169)
I just looked at the GCC contributors list and used an educated estimateof how many on various commercial compilers. I don't have exact numbers, which is why I said "probably".

And we aren't talking only about high-level ideas here, but actual implementation details.

Huh? What implementation details? Citation? Silverlight looks fundamentally different than any other product, except WPF. I'd love to see who their copying implementation details from.

Re:Leaving .Net by decode on Friday December 17, 2010 @09:37AM (#2016285)
Silverlight looks fundamentally different than any other product, except WPF.

Back when my company started using Silverlight, I was surprised to learn that none of my coworkers knew it was almost the same as Adobe Flex. I think this sort of ignorance about the greater world of programming is exactly what the original post is talking about.

Re:Leaving .Net by kenjackson on Friday December 17, 2010 @11:51AM (#2016744)
They're only similar in that they both use markup and code behind. But that's like saying Silverlight and classic ASP are almost the same. With that said, I should have said, at introduction Silverlight looked fundamentally different. Flex has copied what I think is Silverlight (and WPFs) main differentiator, which is lookless controls (which ties into binding).

I think you underestimate the amount of people who have used Flex at some point in time.

Re:Leaving .Net by rbanffy on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @07:43AM (#2007890)
> and arguably stagnant

This is like complaining someone's market share is stagnated around 99%...

As for "working on", it has two interpretations. While I certainly thing GCC has less patches per month accepted into its codebase than clang, there are a whole lot more people compiling C code with it. I would not be surprised if we discovered more code is compiled with GCC than with all other C compilers combined.

Re:Leaving .Net by troygoode on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @08:28AM (#2007995)
I agree with you regarding MVC being effectively a direct copy of a subset of Rails, but what are you suggesting Silverlight is a copy of? Flash? While they're used in similar ways they couldn't be further apart in implementation...