With sway (Wayland port of i3) you can set "workspace_layout tabbed" to have the default container be tabbed, and also top level splits that are created by moving a window out of a tabbed container be tabbed. I think i3 works like this too, but I don't remember well.
The i3 model requires building a strong intuition for how to solve broken layouts, and it can be frustrating until you know how. But once you figure it out it's automatic. It's not for everyone, but a lot of people end up liking it a lot.
One of the dozen users checking in. My favorite feature of ion/notion is the alt-space scratch pad. I always have a bunch of ad-hoc terminals or other programs open that I can easily reach from any desktop. So far I haven't seen any other tiling wm that has something similar. I'm probably wrong though.
i did that with xmonad - set up alt-` to either switch to desktop 10, or if i was on desktop 10, to switch back to the previous desktop.
That's certainly an interesting idea. Thanks!
I have a number of terminals mapped to hyper+[letter] in i3, five are empty with just a shell. Two are Python repls, and the rest are actually various outputs for programs I run where I want to see a log of whats happening
Re:A Tiling Desktop Environment
by rusticpotato on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:50AM
(#20075780)
Uhh i3 has had a scratchpad forever and I use it in tabbed mode with as many tabs as I want
Yep. That's the "I'm probably wrong" part. I knew that i3 had something like that, but I remember that you could only start one program within the scratchpad. If there's a tabbed mode within the scratchpad, I should probably take another look.
Re:A Tiling Desktop Environment
by rusticpotato on Sunday June 02, 2019 @01:56PM
(#20076948)
It’s a bit of a trick. You just have a bunch of tabs and then select all (select the parent) then send the entire parent to scratch pad
I used XMonad for very long time. I briefly tried i3, but I didn't like it.
I actually prefer manual tiling WMs too. So I settled down on StumpWM. It's really good and easy to configure.
It's tiling is like i3 except it uses manual layouts instead of dynamic. So when you create yet another xterm window it does not rearrange all the other tiles on your screen, it just creates a new tab in the current frame. If you want a new horizontal or vertical split, you create it explicitly. I open shells like browser tabs, so if the default was to somehow find screen space for each one, I'd be looking at hundreds of 2x2 sized xterms. Honestly if I could get i3 to behave like this I'd probably switch (and I've tried...I realize you can set a pane into tab mode, but I find it's still too easy to totally mess up your layout if you are not careful in i3. Anyone got tips?).
I also once used Awesome, and the constant reshuffling of the screen layout drove me crazy. Did not really care for the fixed layouts either.