Re:What Is Electricity? (2013)
by lilgreenland on Saturday June 01, 2019 @09:38AM
(#20069110)
Here's my take on a cartoony conductivity simulation. I've got three models: conductors, semiconductors, and semiconductors but with holes.
https://landgreen.github.io/physics/notes/electromagnetism/c...
Yes, that looks much closer to what I have in mind, although I also tend to think of electrons as not visible individually and doing this as part of a large cloud over a 3-D crystalline substrate.
Re:What Is Electricity? (2013)
by dreamcompiler on Saturday June 01, 2019 @12:17PM
(#20069879)
I like these diagrams. Now I want to see what superconductivity looks like in your framework. An unimpeded stream of electrons flowing as if the red dots aren't even there?
Re:What Is Electricity? (2013)
by lilgreenland on Saturday June 01, 2019 @12:27PM
(#20069938)
My simulation just runs classical physics (Coulomb's law + Newton's laws). It's missing any mechanism for super conductivity. Although, I could just turn off friction.
I think superconductivity means the electrons pair up and stop colliding through the Pauli exclusion principle. I didn't code any collisions, so maybe it's already modeling a crappy version of superconductivity!
The distinction is between the speed of propagation (e.g. how fast between a light switch flipping until lighting the room) and the physical movement of subatomic particles through the wire.
Looks like what you are describing is a model of the conductivity in the valence band (of a semiconductor). In the conduction band of a metal electrons move freely, their forward mobility being impeded only by heat.
Well, maybe the part about the holes. But even wikipedia mentions newton's cradle! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_resistivity_and_con...
There is a diagram (an animated GIF) about half-way down that sort of implies the newton's cradle method of moving charge, but I don't like it because it's not clear enough. Also, I see current as more of a fixed cloud of valence electrons with holes moving through it - which is a very different intuition than what this diagram implies.