News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by Consultant32452 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:15PM (#20054914)
Let's work with some simple numbers and think about what's happened in history.

Imagine median worker income in the 1970s was $100. For a lot of women, they weren't allowed to be workers. Let's increase the population of "workers" by 20% (adding those women), but only pay those women $70 (because patriarchy). What's the median income now? $95.

Let's increase the number of "workers" by another 20% by bringing in 30 million immigrants and their descendants. Those immigrants were making $5 in their old country, but they aren't represented in that original $100 median worker salary. But now they're making $60. Better than they were, but worse than white men because racism. What's the median income now? $89.

This is the real story behind all the drama about median wage stagnation, median household income, etc. We added a bunch of lower wage people into the calculation. Those people are better off than they were before, but they drag down the one stat we look at with tunnel vision. That doesn't mean I deny any of the real concerns people have about racism/sexism/etc. But everything can literally be better for everyone, and as I demonstrated above we can still decrease the median household income.

When you say something like "median household income has barely budged in the last twenty years" that's a very shallow assessment. What's happened to the labor market? What's happened to the housing market? Are there more single people as a percentage of the population? Should we expect single households to have the same income as married households? What has been the historical household income for single moms? Are there more single moms today than 20 years ago? How does that impact median household income?

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by mikeash on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:17PM (#20056006)
Average household size hasn’t changed much in the past 20 years. It’s down by about 4% in that time, so that doesn’t explain it. The percentage of the workforce that consists of women is also pretty much flat over that period, and in any case if we’re talking about households and household size hasn’t changed significantly then more women working would increase, not decrease, the median even if they’re underpaid.

Is it all down to underpaid immigrants, then?

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by Consultant32452 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @06:36PM (#20056635)
Solo households, as a percentage, has significantly increased from 17% in 1970 to 28%.

https://articles.ezlandlordforms.com/landlord-and-real-estat...

That should, on average, cut the household income of those houses in half compared to if two of those singles were married and/or living together. I don't know what the data is for just the last 20 years, but taking a small fraction of the households and splitting them up into two households each making half as much puts a big dent in median once you run the math.

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by mikeash on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:57PM (#20057924)
Average household size went from 2.6 in 1999 to 2.5 today. How is that going to put a big dent in the median?
Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by Consultant32452 on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:45AM (#20058712)
Sure, let's make some assumptions to show how the math works out. Let's assume a total population of 10k, every household is a married couple. Each parent is a worker making $50, resulting in every household (two workers) income being our same $100 median.

For a household size of 2.6, we wind up with 3,846 households. If there's 3,846 households with a median income of $100, that makes our total economy $384,600.

Now let's assume enough of those families divorce such that there are now only 2.5 people per household. We wind up with 4,000 households. We still have the same total economy of $384,600 but split across more households (4000) that results in a median household income of $96. That's a 4% drop in median income.

Now of course in real life the change in household size isn't just people getting divorced (or never marrying). It's also reduce birth rate. But I hope you can see how a small change in single people makes a relatively big change in median income.

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by mikeash on Friday May 31, 2019 @09:53AM (#20060848)
A 4% drop in average household size produces a 4% drop in median household income? That’s not a relatively big change, that’s a small change and exactly what I’d expect.

Real per capita GDP rose by around 25% over this period. What accounts for the other 21%?

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by Consultant32452 on Friday May 31, 2019 @11:36AM (#20061852)
The only point I'm making is that the median worker's wage has gone up, in spite of the charts showing the median worker's wage looks flat. We know it's gone up because we've discussed how it if all else were equal it SHOULD be down measurably due to things like there being more single families in the median household chart, adding a lot of lower wage workers through women's rights and immigration on the median worker wage chart.

I'm not making any claims that the gains have been perfectly proportional across all segments of the population. Only that the average worker is really better off today than they were before, and that the median wage charts don't give us very helpful information to gauge how much better/worse off they are.

These new additions to the labor pool don't just add another worker/job at the lower end affecting the median chart, they provide downward pressure on everyone's wages because they compete for those jobs. These workers are productive, so GDP goes up, but there is downward pressure on all wages. That is a big part of the story of the increasing wage/wealth disparity between the rich and everyone else. It's not the only factor, but it's a significant one.

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by mikeash on Friday May 31, 2019 @12:40PM (#20062500)
I said it has "barely budged". A few percent in two decades fits that description.

I don't understand why you bring up women entering the workforce again. As I mentioned, that's wrong twice: the proportion of women in the workforce is flat over this timeframe, and additional women in the workforce would push median household income up, not down.

So we're left with immigrants. Thus my original question way up there: is it all down to underpaid immigrants, then?

Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by Consultant32452 on Friday May 31, 2019 @08:46PM (#20066360)
I'm not sure I can help you. My point is that you seem to be trying to make a political statement based on a single variable in an extremely complex system that is multivariate. As I demonstrated, it's trivially easy for everyone in the system to make more money but for the median household income and/or median wage to go down. But all of my numbers are completely fake. I don't know what the real numbers are or their impacts. And those are just the kinds of things I thought of off the top of my head. I can neither prove or disprove the thing you seem to be alluding to. I'm inclined to agree with what I'm assuming is your intent, but the data available doesn't actually tell that story. Nor does it disprove that story.
Re:The richest 10% of households now represent 70% of all U.... by mikeash on Saturday June 01, 2019 @09:57PM (#20072971)
And yet when we considered the variables you mentioned, the conclusion didn’t change.

What is the point of mentioning that decreasing household size could make the number misleading, when household size didn’t decrease by a significant amount? What is the point of repeatedly bringing up workforce participation by women?

It’s fine to say that a measure might be misleading because of other factors. But when those factors don’t actually make it misleading for the example being discussed, I don’t really get the point.

It’s also weird that you focus entirely on the possibility that everyone is better off. Isn’t it also possible that everyone is worse off while the median household income remains flat? Smells of ideological bias.