Re:Is High Quality Software Worth the Cost?
by BeetleB on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:29AM
(#20051468)
This is my experience as well. I learned the lesson the one time I was allowed to write unit tests at work. It was on an existing code base without tests. I had to significantly refactor code to make it testable, and one of the lessons I learned from the experience is to isolate I/O from the main business logic that I'm testing.
In the pre-test code, the functions were littered with PrintConsole statements that would take a string and a warning level (the Console was an object that was responsible for printing strings on a HW console). I made sure my main business logic was never aware of the Console object. I made an intermediate/interface class that handled all I/O, and mocked that class. Instead, the function now had LogMessage, LogWarning, LogError functions of the interface class that took a string. The function had no idea where these messages could go - it could go to the console, it could be logged to a file, it could be sent as a text message. It didn't care.
Now when we needed to make changes to how things were printed, none of our business logic functions, nor their tests, were impacted. In this case at least, attempting to unit test led to less coupled code.
In the pre-test code, the functions were littered with PrintConsole statements that would take a string and a warning level (the Console was an object that was responsible for printing strings on a HW console). I made sure my main business logic was never aware of the Console object. I made an intermediate/interface class that handled all I/O, and mocked that class. Instead, the function now had LogMessage, LogWarning, LogError functions of the interface class that took a string. The function had no idea where these messages could go - it could go to the console, it could be logged to a file, it could be sent as a text message. It didn't care.
Now when we needed to make changes to how things were printed, none of our business logic functions, nor their tests, were impacted. In this case at least, attempting to unit test led to less coupled code.