Re:Malaysia to send up to 100 tonnes of plastic waste back t...
by nik736 on Friday May 31, 2019 @09:33AM
(#20060681)
Got your points, interesting.
I just wanted to add to your last paragraph that we are paying 25ct per one-way plastic bottle on top of the regular price, we get it back when we return the bottle. That means the return rate is super high, because otherwise people will lose a lot of money. I think the system is quite good.
Re:Malaysia to send up to 100 tonnes of plastic waste back t...
by vidarh on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:52PM
(#20063281)
Same in Scandinavia. I do agree it works well, and it's critical in order to make reuse cost effective, because consider that if you were to have only 10% of bottles not being returned, then that means 10% of bottles are never even available to reuse even once, of the 90% reused, you'd expect 10% (so 9 percentage points) are never reused twice, and so on - drastically driving down the average number of reuses possible even if you assume every returned bottle is perfect.
As far as I can tell return rates in Germany, as in Scandinavia, are much higher than 90% - up to 99% for some categories, so it likely is high enough to be worth it.
Glass bottles are far more energy-expensive to transport. Both filled, but also empty where plastic bottles can be packed far denser.
Reuse of bottles is also not energy-free: it takes transport, where transport of plastic bottles or cans is even cheaper, as depending they may be crushed before transport. After transport, bottles for reuse must be cleaned and sterilized. Combined with the much lower energy costs of recycling a plastic bottle vs. the already low costs of producing one, the difference between reusing a glass bottle and recycling a plastic bottle is low enough that it takes very high return rates and good quality returns to break even.
As far as I remember it certainly is possible and it might well have improved since I last saw numbers, but it's not an automatic given until/unless you have sufficiently high return rates (Germany possibly does - I don't remember the precise return rates, but I believe they're similar to Scandinavia well above 90%), and can ensure you're able to reuse enough times.