Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War...
by FabHK on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:59PM
(#20046991)
Yes. Clearly, there was some failure in systems engineering. And one must look at this very carefully and find out what went wrong such that many good diligent highly qualified people screwed up so royally.
But unreflective ill-informed hostile accusations sometimes seen here (“lies”, “care only about profits”, etc.) is certainly neither appropriate nor helpful in avoiding a repeat of the problem.
It smells like a classic case of under-engineering. In a properly engineered system someone would have asked "What if an AoA sensor fails during flight?" and forced the MCAS to be redesigned. This question would have been asked about every single part of the system before it was deemed ready for production.