To the extent that we want to fund talented but not wealthy kids in the Arts, let's spend the money on explicit scholarships for them. Then at least it's transparent what we are paying for. Much better than funding them by having them take impossible loans funded from some slightly disguised arm of the government, which we will hound them about paying for decades, and eventually write the money off.
"Percentage of future income" sounds like a great model to me, too. IIRC this is what the Australians did? Only I would prefer for the percentage taken to be something negotiated (within limits) by a private lender, because the offers made would provide valuable information to those signing up.
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/03/why-on...
"ISAs provide students money to cover college costs, and in exchange, students agree to pay back a percentage of their future income for a set period of time—interest-free and capped. At Purdue, for example, a senior majoring in economics who took out $13,000 in a “Back a Boiler” ISA would pay 4.39 percent of her income over 100 months, up to a maximum of $32,500."
"If a student struggles to secure a job after graduation or earns less than $20,000 per year, the college would collect no money. If a student is extraordinarily successful financially, Purdue could be paid back up to 250 percent of the amount originally awarded."
> Government funded universities would solve this, because they would set the price, but we'd probably lose out on a lot of great programs. You could also solve this by outlawing charging tuition and switch college funding to being a percent of the graduate's future income. Of course, this would get the colleges to optimize for only majors that have high incomes after graduation, and we'd lose all of our philosophers and writers and artists (which I personally think would be a bad thing).
I disagree that this is a bad thing. We need to stop trying to convince ourselves that college is about turning out "well-rounded individuals". That mentality stems from the roughly 2 centuries when university's job was to socialize elite young men in upper class society. Contemporary university is about preparing individuals with skills that will be desirable in the job market. Charging tuition via income sharing will make colleges emphasize high income majors, which in turn benefits graduates who now have skills to work in high income jobs.
What’s your support for that?
Take even the most elite school, Harvard. Engineering since the early 1800’s. And how many of those med, law, and divinity students weren’t there for vocational training?
Today, some liberal arts colleges (including some engineering colleges) still require a core curriculum, but such a thing is increasingly rare at large universities, and non-existent at public schools. Moreover, even among the liberal arts colleges, a broad classical education is exceedingly rare, except for a few colleges like Thomas Aquinas.
Then when it became career training, the government stepped in and provided a lot of money to help non-wealthy people enter the system, which was probably a good thing. The unintended consequence of that was that colleges starts sucking up all that money the government was giving out, creating a vicious cycle.
Government funded universities would solve this, because they would set the price, but we'd probably lose out on a lot of great programs. You could also solve this by outlawing charging tuition and switch college funding to being a percent of the graduate's future income. Of course, this would get the colleges to optimize for only majors that have high incomes after graduation, and we'd lose all of our philosophers and writers and artists (which I personally think would be a bad thing).
Maybe there is a hybrid approach here, were you can choose to pay now or pay later with a percent of your income. Those that choose pay later would most likely be forced to choose a "high potential earning" major, and those that paid now could choose whatever they want. But then this would lead us back to only wealthy kids being able to afford "the arts".