Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by Aleul on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @09:59AM
(#2004346)
What would you recommend doing then? (New to this stuff)
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by rmc on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @10:27AM
(#2004435)
I suspect tptacek will come in with some sound advise. But bcrypt seems to be the way forward.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by sparky on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @11:55AM
(#2004759)
bcrypt or scrypt (http://www.tarsnap.com/scrypt.html).
bcrypt lets you more or less arbitrarily set the computational complexity (in terms of instructions) of key generation. scrypt is newer (2009), but has the attractive property that it lets you arbitrarily set the memory complexity instead (how much memory it takes). This is attractive because key generation with a large memory requirement is more expensive to massively parallelize with an ASIC/FPGA farm.
If you have a seriously good reason for not using either of these, which you probably don't, "stretched" (iterated thousands of times) and salted SHA-2 or MD5, or PBKDF2 ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PBKDF2 ) can be acceptable alternatives.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by Aleul on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @02:26PM
(#2005376)
Thanks a bunch rmc, and sparky! I'll definitely be spending some time reading up on these tonight.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by rorrr on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @11:25AM
(#2004633)
That's just not true. If your salt is 1000 characters long, they will need more energy than the whole universe has to bruteforce it.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by ent on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @05:26PM
(#2005989)
the point of adding a salt to the passwords is not to make decrypting the individual passwords harder - the salts are kept in plaintext - but to make it impossible to prevent the use of rainbow tables. that is, having longer salts will only make it harder for finding out all the people with the same password.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by rorrr on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @10:48PM
(#2006965)
That's assuming hacker knows the salt, which is not always the case.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by rmc on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @04:48AM
(#2007596)
My prediction: After there are loads of MD5 rainbow tables with all the passwords a human could use, people will make rainbow tables with salts. First one byte of salt, then two. Granted this gets exponentially harder, but eventually it'll be close.
Re:Whitepixel v2 now brute forcing 33.1 billion password/sec
by tedunangst on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @11:30AM
(#2004651)
Except anybody playing this game has the salt, there's no need to guess it.
This only gets faster, not slower. No matter how much you salt your passwords, soon they will be able to crack your passwords fast enough. And soon there will be rainbow tables of salts.