This sort of thing basically existed in 1800's with surgeons. They weren't valued for their work and had a social stigma placed upon them. It took surgery a century to dig out of that hole, only thanks to the people who were dedicated enough to it.
This is the point I’m making. Skills matter and it may be worth it to pursue a skill-based degree but knowledge is cheap. Why spend $30k/yr getting a degree in neuroscience when you could buy the same textbooks, memorize the same information and yet only spend a few hundred dollars on the books themselves?
I’m not saying neuroscience knowledge isn’t valuable, I’m saying it doesn’t make sense to go get a 4 year degree out of it. The most valuable things I gained out of my college experience were extracurriculars working in a research lab (gained practical research skills), leadership skills from starting and running student organizations, and work skills from a part time job.
And there certainly still would be textbooks even if there were no undergraduate neuroscience major. You could still pursue a graduate degree where you take some classes but then spend most of your time building skills and working toward a real contribution to the field.
Surgery wasn't valued because it was mostly a quack science at the time.
I'm at the point in my life where I'm regretful the other direction. I wish I could go back in time and double major or minor in creative writing. I have the money and decent career, now I'm working on getting good at something I'm passionate about.
You could have used it as a basis for a career in pharmaceutical research, medicine, investing, venture capital, science journalism, psychology, machine learning, etc.
If you had an engineering degree, you could say that is useless because your current job as a stage actor doesn't utilize any of those learned skills.
I'm not trying to make a subjective point that neuroscience was bad for me. I turned out ok in the end, I'm a physician now. I'm making the distinction between knowledge-based degrees (which are easily learned outside of paying for a degree) and skill-based degrees, which may include stage acting. You can't learn stage acting from a book, you can learn neuroscience facts from a book.
If I had a math degree, I could have still gone to medical school, and could still become a psychiatrist. But I would have also been able to appreciate Einstein's theory of relativity (as a recreational endeavor) or been able to contribute to the burgeoning field of computational psychiatry as a clinician-researcher.
Now consider an alternative path, I majored in mathematics, joined a quantitative hedge fund and realized I was losing my soul and wanted to do something more fulfilling. So I take my spoils and enroll in some stage acting classes, and eventually land a nice role at a local playhouse. Is my math degree useless? Perhaps not very useful to my stage acting career, but at least I can appreciate the beauty of Einstein's theory of relativity. Or go back to a quant hedge fund if acting doesn't work out. Or many, many other things, because I have a skill that is foundational to many other areas.
Most of my time in undergrad was spent memorizing theorems. Probably not much different than neuroscience. It's really no different than many classes. A lot of bullshit memorization because you need to remember a bunch of one-off shit to solve a lot of problems. Theorems are the jeopardy trivia of math degrees. You know how psychological thriller movies have subtle hints through them that things are not what they seem? It's like, you'd be able to guess what's gonna happen next if you picked up on that super subtle clue 2 hours ago. Most math exams and homework are that. Hope you remember that stupid theorem from 15 chapters ago that was subtly referenced and never mentioned again!
> Now consider an alternative path, I majored in mathematics, joined a quantitative hedge fund
Very unlikely unless ivy league, strong connections, and were working hard outside of your math classes. Job prospects for math majors are grim. You don't learn employable skills in many math degrees. (Speaking mostly of undergrad degrees)
There are certain fields of study that lend themselves to a college format, where you'd benefit from doing things hands on with lectures and instruction.
Not every field of study, including those that can be extremely valuable, has this feature. Acknowledging that the one-size-fits-all college lecture/homework/test format is not the ideal way to learn everything might help us figure out how to learn more efficiently.
Most of the math I know is not due to have amazing mentorship but being forced to do the exercises day in day out.
Meanwhile I still remember the basics of calculus from AP calculus in high school and it has become useful to me. I strongly regret not majoring in something skill-based like math or engineering because those are things that are much harder to teach yourself without mentorship, they tend to stick with you longer, and they make up the foundation skills for so many other areas.
But I had no disincentive for choosing neuroscience. I was attracted to the subject and so thought it was reasonable to major in it, not taking into consideration its long term value. If a neuroscience degree came with a black box warning or student loans weren’t so easy to get with that degree or if there was a social stigma to choosing useless degrees then maybe I would have been nudged toward math or computer science.
Anyone can study neuroscience in their spare time but it becomes increasingly difficult to spare the time to learn something like quantum field theory in your own time outside of college. Already having a strong math background would make self-teaching complex mathematical subjects like that do-able. Whole swaths of human intellectual achievement are effectively out of reach to me due to my limited math skills.