News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by ElFitz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:58AM (#20039018)
Reminds me of what people used to say about website builders such as dreamweaver, then about the "cloud", and more recently about "serverless".

Wix and squarespace are more than enough for many businesses' needs. AWS has blown through the roof. And more and more people discover what it feels like not to have to worry about hardware and VMs configuration.

ForestAdmin is also a nice case in point, supposing you have the proper stack.

Sure there will always some who need developers, and most "solutions" this far haven't been up to the task. But I definitely wouldn't bet that won't ever be more than enough for most people and use cases.

For this, extensibility (via integrations and proper established languages; definitely not some absurd and ill-conceived "very friendly script language") will be key

Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by sheeshkebab on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:05AM (#20039075)
I don’t think the article is about “serverless” - it’s more about various BPM, RPA and similar tools and technologies that tend to popup with snake oil type marketing every a couple of years.

Also serverless is arguable more complex for a business person/analyst to grasp than just telling a developer to create something they imagined.

Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by ElFitz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:08AM (#20039091)
Serverless is to sysadmins what codeless is to web developers (front and / or back).

Or serverless is to those same web developers what codeless is to business people.

Edit: also, this is an analogy

Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by sheeshkebab on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:19AM (#20039170)
Yes, analogy is similar, the gap though is much larger (even though it’s barely noticeable).

I guess eventually a new gen of Excel comes out that can write code without IF, FOR loops, and function calls, but until then it’s safe to say anything writing those statements other than in code is pretty much snake oil.

Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by cosmodisk on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @02:22PM (#20043602)
The problem is that IF ELSE statement or even calling some functions is easy, however most people are shit scared of it.A person of very average intelligence can do it,but most people will never dare even to try,hence the popularity of all sorts of drag&drop. Another problem is that if one isn't a developer,it is close to impossible to estimate how difficult the task could be. For instance, querying 1000 records in the database is easy but doing the same for millions of records doesn't translate into "oh, let's just do it a few more times".
Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by ElFitz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:28AM (#20039878)
Oh, I definitely agree with you here. If it were just as "easy", AWS, GCP or Azure would have done it by now.
Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by raiflip on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:52AM (#20040861)
Serverless solutions still need someone to write the code to run on the serverless platform. Serverless doesn't mean literally no servers, it just means the servers are 100% managed by the provider. For example Lambda AWS still needs a developer to upload the code for the Lambda to run.
Re:Why Codeless Software Is Doomed to Fail by ElFitz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @02:54PM (#20043973)
Yes. I know. This has been my job for the past months, and all my personal projects for the past 2 and a half years. Still, no sysadmin.

As for the rest. No-code / low-code solutions don't just pass nice drawings / uml diagram to a gremlins-powered CPU. They rely (and will rely) on code behind the scenes.

Analogy still stands