Re:New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
by klmr on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:08AM
(#20038416)
Nice explanation but you seem to be saying that at most 3% (being generous) of DNA would be functional (if the rest is “random noise”). This number is over twice as small as the lowest estimate (~ 8%) of even the most fervent critics of ENCODE’s number. I’d love to hear a brief break-down of your reasons, if possible.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
by astazangasta on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @11:54AM
(#20041665)
Eh, I graduated in 2008. ENCODE was only a pilot yet. We didn't know about lincRNAs. My estimate was based on multi-species sequence alignments so it is pretty conservative. At the time it was not, however; it was doubling the amount of functional sequence. To be honest i am not sure what the current best estimates are based on (i switched fields). 8% seems absurdly high to me, but there is a ton more evidence now than i had.
Re:New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
by klmr on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @12:44PM
(#20042388)
Ah, I misunderstood your commend as saying that you’re currently working on the thesis.
Re:New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
by mnw21cam on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:43AM
(#20038922)
As an added complication, a decent proportion of DNA in the genome is meaningful at least in how long it is, because it separates two functional pieces of DNA that interact in 3D space due to the way the DNA wraps around other stuff. If you change the content of this DNA, it doesn't cause disease, but if you change the length, it does.