News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by ionised on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:10AM (#20037791)
Or people enjoy soda because the of insane amount of sugar put in it by people intending to make the product as addictive as possible.

Remove the sugar from soda and you have awful-tasting water.

Sugary drinks are no better than cigarettes, and the people pushing them know exactly what they are doing and what they are exploiting.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:45AM (#20037999)
You can make anything sound absurd by reducing it to its ingredients like that.

And anyway, value is determined by the buyer. You can't say as an individual that something has no value to society.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by ionised on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:27AM (#20038824)
> And anyway, value is determined by the buyer.

I disagree. You can make anything seem valuable by defining value in the most cynically narrow terms possible like that.

By that same logic, heroin has great value in society, and hitmen and we shouldn't be trying to stop these things. However we do, because the popularity of the product is no measure of its contribution to society.

Continue on with that logic and literally everything is valuable, making it a meaningless distinction.

> You can't say as an individual that something has no value to society.

I can and did. It's an opinion not an assertion.

If you are creating a need that didn't already exist, like targeting people's predisposition to addictions to substances like sugar, or nicotine, or heroin, then I posit that you have created no real value whatsoever.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:30AM (#20038838)
By your logic music and art have no value to society, because there was no need for those until they were invented, someone could assess their value as zero, they consume natural resources which harms all of us, and the people could be doing something more productive (by some unstated metric of yours) instead.

You just don't enjoy soda. There's nothing wrong with other people enjoying it. Either in moderation, or irresponsibly in our opinion, which is their own business. Other people don't enjoy music and art and should probably think they should be done away with you like you with soda.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by ionised on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:03AM (#20039066)
Art and music aren't produced with the intention of fostering addictions in people. They don't cause death and suffering simply by being sold, or even being abused (how would one abuse art or music?).

So no, that's not my logic at all. There was already a need for art and music. There wasn't already a need for Coca Cola and Lucky Strikes.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:06AM (#20039079)
I don't accept that sodas are either. I think they're a honest product. They aren't healthy, but they don't pretend to be. They say very clearly what they contain and they're marketed as a treat. They are optimised to be as delicious as possible I'm sure, but singers also optimise their songs to be as pleasing as possible so you'll buy their next album.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by nanny on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:19PM (#20044903)
If they're an "honest product" then why do they put caffeine in them? Caffeine doesn't change the flavor to make it "as delicious as possible".
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:07AM (#20049288)
Kola nuts, which contain caffeine, were in the original formulation. It's a stimulant - that's partly what some people are drinking Coca Cola and similar drinks for in the first place. It wasn't added later to increase sales.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by nanny on Thursday May 30, 2019 @08:46AM (#20050565)
Right, but nowadays there's no reason for it to be in there. You said they're marketed as a treat, and optimized to be as delicious as possible. So what's the caffeine for then? They're not marketed as energy drinks or designed to be as stimulating as possible.

I say that the caffeine is in there solely to keep people addicted to it even more.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Thursday May 30, 2019 @11:26AM (#20052176)
> So what's the caffeine for then?

Part of being an enjoyable experience - not literally part of being delicious but part of being a sensation people enjoy.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chillwaves on Sunday June 02, 2019 @03:29PM (#20077483)
The answer is that caffeine is addictive and the soda companies are selling drugs.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by ionised on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:31AM (#20039292)
> hey aren't healthy, but they don't pretend to be. They say very clearly what they contain and they're marketed as a treat

Soda manufacturers include this information because they are required to by law. It is in their interests to hide this information from you.

Lobbysists for junk food manufacturers are always hard at work fighting against these kinds of regulations, because you knowing what is in their product is harmful to their bottom line, because they are selling you what amounts to a mild poison.

People fought to get this labelling required by law. These companies aren't doing it out of the goodness of their hearts.

> They are optimised to be as delicious as possible I'm sure, but singers also optimise their songs to be as pleasing as possible so you'll buy their next album.

The difference being my health isn't harmed by a pop singer trying to improve their voice. Nor are they creating a need or addiction to music that didn't already exist. There has always been a need for music among humans. Even tribal war drums count as music.

I'll concede that most pop music is lowest-common denominator crap manufactured and marketed to as as wide a demographic as possible for no other reason than profit, but really, pop music is such a small part of the entire musical landscape.

Even if it were, what damage to people is pop music causing? What addictions is it fostering?

You could debate about the dumbing down of music that manufactured pop music encourages, but we are talking about actual harm caused by fostering addictions here, which things like sodsa and cigarettes do, as a result of their being addictive as well as damaging to health.

The pop music analogy isn't a very good one, because music doesn't damage your health by encouraging your addiction to substances harmful to your health.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by chrisseaton on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:37AM (#20039357)
> I'll concede that most pop music is lowest-common denominator crap manufactured and marketed to as as wide a demographic as possible for no other reason than profit

Bah I think you're showing yourself to be a cynic and a snob with statements like this. You don't like that music so it's 'lowest-common denominator crap' and you can't see any purpose for it apart from profit, no matter if other people chose to enjoy it.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by ionised on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:51AM (#20040849)
I'm not being a cynic and a snob. There are studies showing how much simpler, more generified and more homogenous and less dynamic pop music has become over the last few decades.

It's an actual thing that has happened.

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/is-pop-mus...

https://www.theguardian.com/music/2012/jul/27/pop-music-soun...

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...

You didn't address the point of my post though, the pop music analogy was just an example you used that I felt didn't work very well because music, even pop music, doesn't harm your health or exploit addictions in the ways many advertised products do.