News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by kortilla on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @03:01AM (#20037485)
>The Mises Institute has put it up for free, which is surely off-message but whatever.

Ah, a clearly well-rationed article is at foot. Here’s a hint, if someone isn’t able to model free things in their understanding of capitalist systems, they don’t understand them enough to critique them.

Anyway, the rest of that “critique” isn’t actually a critique. It’s just goal post shifting to the point where it assumes socialist systems by nature have perfect demand discovery mechanisms (none of which are alluded to) and can never produce a surplus. Conveniently, it follows that clearly socialist systems are perfectly efficient and do not allow surpluses because they have this neat built in mechanism of perfect demand discovery.

So it’s “not true socialism” if there are any inefficiencies in food production, energy production, etc because “true socialism” has a mechanism by which everyone gets exactly what they need.

Did someone inform the author of this that such a mechanism has never existed and the most efficient mechanism we have discovered so far is markets?

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by rexpop on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @03:29PM (#20044349)
> the most efficient mechanism we have discovered so far is markets?

This thread originated in a discussion of the detriments of advertising, I would remind you. The "markets" we're currently employing to "discover demand" find greater profit in engendering it.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by mbrock on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:16AM (#20037827)
Also in true socialism there will be no exchange of consumption goods between people. How will this be enforced? Hmm, let’s not think about that.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by rexpop on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:10PM (#20046131)
It's not a question of enforcement, but incentivization.