News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by csomar on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @01:10AM (#20037006)
> and all of these industries you name exist and pay well because people value them and choose to spend their money on them.

I think his point is, these industries are not valuable to people; they are just aggressive at extract wealth from other people. In net, they have a negative value (from his perspective) and thus society will be better without them.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by foldingmoney on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:06AM (#20037766)
No one's being forced to buy soda, eat highly processed food, have a credit card, or use a car dealership. Yet people voluntarily choose to spend their money on these things, so they obviously do find some value in them.

When you characterise them as 'not valuable to people', you're making a prescriptive moral judgement (and not one I necessarily disagree with), as opposed to a descriptive observation of where free agents choose to spend their money.

I don't drink soda or eat highly processed food, I don't have a credit card, and I didn't buy my car from a dealership. But the fact that many people choose to spend their money on all these things tells me that those people do see value in them, and I don't think my preferences are right and theirs are wrong.

Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by piva00 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:28AM (#20037895)
You lost me on "free agents", under the kind of system of advertising and PR we are under there is a very narrow window of "free agency".
Re:Advertising as a source of dissatisfaction: cross-nationa... by foldingmoney on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:01AM (#20038382)
If the advertising industry is such a powerful force of mind control that we literally have no free will anymore, then why did they let _you_ figure it out?

You're giving them way too much credit. Do you notice how the world is full of failed advertising campaigns? How the world is full of failed companies and failed products that the evil geniuses in advertising weren't able to make people buy?

There's a world of difference between 'we can use some principles from psychology to try to exploit people's fears and make them more interested in our product' and 'our unlimited powers of persuasion make free will an illusion'. And despite the hype, most big-data, machine learning, 'downloading your thoughts from Facebook before you've even had them'-style targeted advertising amounts to showing you ads for the thing that you just bought.