News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by plinkplonk on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:05AM (#20028667)
Why is this newsworthy? Genuine question. The article (I did read it!) doesn't seem to articulate why exactly this is a problem.

I think (happy to be convinced otherwise) it is ok for a company to have more temps than employees or vice versa. What does it matter? Is there a US cultural/social nuance that I'm missing?

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by r3bl on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:26AM (#20028754)
Lower paychecks (75-80% of hourly rate of full-time workers), little to no benefits (like healthcare coverage), harder to keep track of for taxation purposes, harder to object to inhumane conditions like exploitative working hours or sexual harassment (since you're seen as a "guest" instead of an employee, complaining to the HR will usually result in you simply being discarded and replaced by someone else who won't complain) etc.

Note: I wrote this as a general trend, which does not mean this applies to Google specifically.

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by C1sc0cat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @08:07AM (#20029236)
Is this like for like? your not going to pay a security guard the same as a SRE are you.

If I went as a contactor in the UK id expect 2x to 3x when compared to a FTE at a similar grade.

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by r3bl on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:06AM (#20029583)
Just because we're in a position to say no doesn't mean that we shouldn't feel compassion for the others that are not in an opportunity to do so. A tech office without a janitor will be dysfunctional, same as the one without a senior engineer. But unlike a senior engineering position, a janitor will not be a full-time position.

I'd personally even take it one step further: those who are payed the least need benefits the most. By relegating this work to temporary workers you're doing exactly the opposite: cutting away the privileges that the full-time employees have. Not to just one employee, but anyone who's ever going to fill out that position.

A trip to the doctor would not make a dent in a senior engineer's pocket (regardless of the insurance), but a janitor could not afford a trip to the doctor in the first place. This could work in a country with good social programs to fall back on, but it has catastrophic consequences in the US.

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by CydeWeys on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:02AM (#20030800)
I agree in general terms, but the solution would be to pass stricter laws requiring more benefits to full-time workers. These contractors are full-time workers, they're just full-time workers of staffing firms that contract with Google and that themselves don't have benefits that are nearly as good. So either require them to offer better benefits, or preferably, decouple benefits from employment entirely. Everyone should get healthcare, retirement accounts, etc.; it shouldn't be tied to your employer.

It's unreasonable to expect one company to make big strides in this area when all it does it put them at a competitive disadvantage to their peers. Google is already mandating a $15/hour minimum wage on all contracted-out workers, plus some minimums for sick days, which is much better than most other companies (which tend not to have requirements on contracted out employees in their contracts with staffing firms at all).

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by r3bl on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:13AM (#20030928)
This is precisely why I added that note in my first comment. I'm talking about general trends as a response to this:

> What does it matter? Is there a US cultural/social nuance that I'm missing?

I'm not familiar enough with Google's specific practices to reach a conclusion about that.

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by CydeWeys on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:28AM (#20031104)
Fair enough. My view is that Google is better than most, in that they have better requirements on their staffing firms: https://phys.org/news/2019-04-google-require-benefits-minimu...
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by C1sc0cat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:24AM (#20030318)
Oh I agree.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by cosmie on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:24PM (#20032245)
Contractors for large companies[1] in the US almost always goes through staffing firms - direct contracts with independent contractors are comparatively rare. And even when you do want to bring on an independent contractor, you usually still have to route them through some designated third party staffing firm so that the contractual relationship is IC <-> Staffing Firm <-> Client. This is all due to fact that there are huge liability[2] concerns related to classifying someone as an IC but treating them as an employee.

As such, there's almost always an intermediate taking a cut of the actual rate, even if you're a contractor to the staffing agency.

Then you've got agency relationships, like where I work at now. I'm a salaried, full time employee for the agency I work for and I make about the regional median for my role. But I'm contracted out to clients (including Google) and bill hourly. Depending on the client and the specific roles I'm billing as for a given project, an hour of my time gets billed out anywhere from 2x - 6x what my fully loaded hourly cost is to my employer (salary + benefits + payroll taxes). So the cost to the client is certainly in line with your expectations, but it doesn't come back to me.

[1] You don't see this as frequently at the SME end of the market for many reasons, not least of which is the deliberate inefficiency and increased costs of such a structure.

[2] https://www.reuters.com/article/businesspropicks-us-findlaw-...

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:33AM (#20037921)
That's what most of us do in the UK though self-employed contractors use a third-party firm just for billing which is just a few quid a week.

Though that link is just showing how incompetent MS Hr was - when it happened I recall having a good laugh with some Colleagues who work in HR/IR

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by funkjunky on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:45AM (#20040776)
It depends. For some contractor jobs, they need high level engineers short term and don't want to deal with the normal Google hiring process, which is expensive, difficult, and time consuming for many current employees (most technical interviews at Google are carried out by a random assortment of other engineers). In those cases, they can and will often pay equal or higher salaries to the contractor.

In my case, the equivalent job at Google definitely carried more responsibilities, and they were paid more. However, I believe Google paid my consulting company more than the FTE salary for each of us, with my company taking their cut off the top (at least, that's what I heard).

In short, it's complicated

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by maxxxxx on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:57AM (#20030756)
“If I went as a contactor in the UK id expect 2x to 3x when compared to a FTE at a similar grade.”

At least in the US that’s often not how it works. The agency takes a big cut and the contractor probably makes less than an FTE. In my company must contractors are super eager to go full time given the opportunity.

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:44AM (#20029900)
Staffers have undeniably more leverage that contractors. So yes, on an 'all things equal' basis, this will come out oddly.

It's one thing to outsource security, another to outsource people who work as part of the organization: admins, executive assistants, developers, recruiters etc..

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @08:04PM (#20035676)
Perhaps, until a shooter shows up at the youtube office and starts firing and then kills herself in front of you. That did happen and can happen at any firm, tech or otherwise.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by closeparen on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:01PM (#20036517)
Occupations paying differently is a major component of inequality, yes.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by AmericanChopper on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @07:30AM (#20029037)
When I was contracting, I was making significantly more than my usual salaried rate. Using contractors doesn’t mean you must be exploiting them somehow.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by acdha on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @07:47AM (#20029125)
You have to remember that we’re a couple decades into reclassifying jobs with less negotiating power as contractors and healthcare costs growing astronomically (not unrelated). The people who are still doing traditional contracting - short-term experts, independent businesses which can negotiate – are going to have a very different experience than the people who were never respected.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by brianwawok on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @07:38AM (#20029076)
Porn filter temps or any of the low end temps aren’t paid like developer contractors.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by rchaud on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:05AM (#20030838)
The article brought up a few points that should encourage broader discussion, around the general idea that contractors don't have the same agency as FTEs, which in the case of Google, has reportedly led to:

- project leaders pressuring contractors to work longer hours than stated in their contracts without reporting overtime (on the vague possibility of a full-time role).

- the contractor recruiter who was sexually harassed by a FTE manager and may have been fired due to her rejection of him

Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by radmuzom on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:23AM (#20029716)
It provides a specific example of the power imbalance between Googlers and non-Googlers. It provides some facts on how temps make less money, have different benefits and receive no paid vacation in the US. Probably far-fetched, but it may be hoping to convince some people to engage with their elected representatives on stricter laws for companies who employ a lot of contractors. Why is this not newsworthy?
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by ng12 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:51AM (#20029963)
Because it's literally business as usual. Companies do not have to offer benefits in the US, Google or no.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by CydeWeys on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:06AM (#20030845)
Companies shouldn't be providing benefits anyway. It's a terrible model. Much better for the government to be providing healthcare for all than to have it unnecessarily tied up with employment. The United States is unusual in this regard because of a historical quirk of tax evasion.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:38AM (#20030511)
That's why it's newsworthy. A lot of people don't know that this is what "business as usual" looks like.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by radmuzom on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:30AM (#20030422)
All the more reason to publish it, raise awareness and try to change the status quo.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by dao- on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:15AM (#20028705)
It matters to the workers? I guess there is a cultural aspect, then, playing into this question: (How much) do you care about worker rights?
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by e40 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:14AM (#20030200)
It's been in the news so much that I think they assumed you would not that contractors don't get benefits, like health insurance. Lack of benefits are the reason they are contactors. Period.
Re:Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time... by CydeWeys on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:05AM (#20030832)
Negative, the contractors being discussed in the linked article are actually full time employees of staffing firms. They aren't employed by Google, they're employed by the likes of Adecco. Their healthcare isn't as good as what Google itself offers, granted, but they do have some benefits.

There's an incredible amount of conflation here between individuals that are directly contracted to companies (what most of these comments seem to be talking about) and then what actually happens at large corporations (staffing firms that contract out their own employees).