Agreed - great insight. And this effect is exacerbated when there is genuine malicious intent on the internet. I've sat with my mum or dad on several occasions, when they've been confused by 'ads' on websites which are designed to look like dialog boxes.
It was far too difficult for me to explain how to tell that this was not a legitimate dialog box. Or understand the concept of phishing.
In other words, we're just iterating on trying things [as xkcd observed][0]. The key is that inside that first decision box, locating an action to try, we have a huge leg up on the "...which looks related to what you want to do" part. I sometimes describe this as "knowing how computers think", but really it's knowing how the people that wrote the program think.
Not that it's an easy problem, but I think we still have a lot of work to do as a field, to make stuff accessible to people whose brains don't follow the same patterns as ours.
[0]:https://www.xkcd.com/627/