I'm American. I have also seen comments on HN from people in very poor parts of the world. I don't think I'm the poorest person on HN.
Yes, the population on HN skews towards the well heeled, apparently pretty strongly. But I have zero reason to believe that all participants here are globally in the top ten percent for wealth/income. And, in fact, I have reason to believe otherwise.
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/11/07/how-much-money-you-need-to-b...
A net worth of $93,170 U.S. is enough to make you richer than 90 percent of people around the world
That absolutely does not include me.
https://www.quora.com/What-salary-in-the-world-puts-you-in-t...
Meh, tired of looking for a definitive figure.
Could you either kindly provide an exact figure on annual income for the top ten percent, or walk that claim back and admit you were in error on your assumptions about the readership here or both?
Because I've been a regular participant for nearly a decade and I've been dirt poor for most of that time.
Thanks.
Source: http://www.globalrichlist.com
So I don't think wealth measured in dollars is a good metric.
We don't have to talk hypotheticals - people living off $1000 a year around the globe are able to have children and families, whereas in the US, they are not (in any significant amount).
And the economic opportunities in the US aren't relevant - we're trying to compare living on $1000 in the US vs. developing world, so adding 'economic opportunities' is saying "it's better to live on $1000 in the US because you'll be able to make more than $1000".
Pan handling, charitable services and governmental programs are not counted against that $1000 a year either.
>We don't have to talk hypotheticals - people living off $1000 a year around the globe are able to have children and families, whereas in the US, they are not (in any significant amount).
People who subsist solely on governmental benefits often have children. In fact the poor have more children than the wealthy. Compare Mexican birth rates per capita to the US, then compare African birth rates to Mexico if you don't believe me. Not having children is a sign of a wealthy society.
>And the economic opportunities in the US aren't relevant - we're trying to compare living on $1000 in the US vs. developing world, so adding 'economic opportunities' is saying "it's better to live on $1000 in the US because you'll be able to make more than $1000".
Any American who works more than 3 hours a week will be over that $1000 a year. Unemployment is virtually zero. Those who are unable to work get SSI.
California is currently experiencing a resurgence of "medieval diseases" that is believed to have started in the homeless population.
I lived in a tent for nearly six years. I wouldn't want anything to do with a tent city in a major metropolitan area.
Second, that income supports three adults. While homeless, I knew other homeless people who had a higher per capita income than us.
Currently, I have reason to believe that I'm one of the poorest people in the building I live in.
I'm pretty damn poor for an American.
You are also ignoring my previous statement that I've seen comments here from people from third world countries.
My essential point is that, no, not all people reading HN are rich. I have no problem agreeing that most (more than 50% of) people here are well off. That seems like a reasonable assertion.
But it doesn't take much to indicate that your addition of "if not all" is almost certainly not true.
Let me put it this way, if all global income were distributed equally it would be roughly ten thousand dollars a year per person. That's all in. Roads, police, social programs, private spending. Ten thousand dollars is the average household income in China. That's a the most fair distribution possible.
Do you know what the per median per capita income is in India? A growing nation with a tech sector and nuclear weapons? Less than $700 a year. Here's the worst bit, people in India are also disabled and deal with the same personal struggles that you do.
I'm not saying this to trivialize your life but the facts have to be put into perspective. People living in western nations, speaking English and with internet access really don't have the right to call themselves poor. Comparatively poor yes, nominally poor? Check your privilege.
There are lots of people here who are not living in Western nations.
I'm done arguing this. Your remarks are not remotely in good faith.
We. Unless you are a extreme outlier here. The top 1% globally make 32k USD a year and up. I'd assume the vast majority if not all of the people reading this are in the top 10%.