Re:The frontpage with a threshold of 100 points
by tptacek on Monday December 13, 2010 @12:45AM
(#1999491)
Comments are sorted based in part on votes. That's fine. The system we have now isn't picking out the best comments; it's picking out my comments.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The frontpage with a threshold of 100 points
by alexophile on Monday December 13, 2010 @11:18AM
(#2000899)
I like using votes to determine whether or not it's worth devling into a deep thread. If there's a conversation that goes 5 levels deep, you can just scan the bottom layers - if they're getting votes, then it's likely to be a worthwhile conversation.
Similarly, if there's a bunch of responses with a score of 1 with replies forking off all over the place, having a visible score lets you catch that at-a-glance and avoid bothering with a conversation that is clearly digressing.